Water Mill New York homes for sale starting at Fifty Thousand Dollars

$5,900,000 - Water Mill, NY

117 Mill Creek Close Water Mill, NY - Every single thing you could possibly desire in a Hamptons home is here for you in this completely renovated and redesigned, natural light-filled dream house. Located South of the Highway in the best neighborhood in Water Mill, this thoughtfully curated estate has it all. There's pool, tennis, pickle ball, and a welcoming walkable community outside. Inside, every single living space has been gorgeously appointed and comes with plenty of space to stretch out and enjoy your best time ever in the Hamptons. The 4,918-square-foot, two-story home features six bedrooms and five-and-a-half baths, including a first-floor primary with deck and pool access; an open chef's kitchen leading to adjoining dining and living room with fireplace-each with walkout access to the pool and courts; an upstairs hangout space; plus, game and gathering spaces, and a workout room in the lower level. Additional amenities include a Sonos system, two-car garage with circular drive, and excellent rental history. Close to farmstands, spa, shops, restaurants, museums, and your choice of ocean beaches.

$5,900,000 - Water Mill, NY

117 Mill Creek Close Water Mill, NY - Every single thing you could possibly desire in a Hamptons home is here for you in this completely renovated and redesigned, natural light-filled dream house. Located South of the Highway in the best neighborhood in Water Mill, this thoughtfully curated estate has it all. There's pool, tennis, pickle ball, and a welcoming walkable community outside. Inside, every single living space has been gorgeously appointed and comes with plenty of space to stretch out and enjoy your best time ever in the Hamptons. The 4,918-square-foot, two-story home features six bedrooms and five-and-a-half baths, including a first-floor primary with deck and pool access; an open chef's kitchen leading to adjoining dining and living room with fireplace-each with walkout access to the pool and courts; an upstairs hangout space; plus, game and gathering spaces, and a workout room in the lower level. Close to farmstands, spa, shops, restaurants, museums, and your choice of ocean beaches.

$5,850,000 - Water Mill, NY

87 Westminster Road Water Mill, NY - Originally designed by Neski and seamlessly reimagined by Bates Masi, available for sale for the first time, it is a masterclass in coastal contemporary living - with room for a pool. A portrait of Hamptons living, clad in cedar-shake siding and sited on over half an acre boasting 3,195 +/- sq. ft. of luxury living space with waterviews from every room 3 bedrooms and 3.5 baths. This Calf Creek location affords an undisturbed vantage of natural wildlife season after season. Interiors are impeccably maintained, highlighted by a contemporary stainless steel staircase, antique exposed beams, wood-burning fireplace in the den, and a beautiful Bisazza tiled powder room. Each bedroom is ready to accommodate guests, plus the ensuite primary with cathedral ceiling has a luxe Bisazza tiled bathroom with glass-walled shower, and radiant heated floors. The living room beams with light from windows on three sides and a stunning skylight built into the tall, arched ceiling. Open to the dining and living room, the kitchen has Terrazzo floors, stainless steel appliances, two dishwashers and stainless and granite countertops. Easy access to the patio with a retractable awning ensures effortless entertaining and unforgettable waterfront vistas for sun lounging and dining al fresco. Outdoors, enjoy the beautiful landscaping, outdoor shower, and your own dock on the bay for easy boating to the ocean. An oversized, heated 2-car garage and bonus space above complete this rare and special waterfront offering enviably located in West Mecox on a quiet street abutting Calf Creek and moments from Mecox Bay and easy access to farm stands, restaurants and ocean beaches.

$5,500,000 - Water Mill, NY

94 Lower 7 Ponds Road Water Mill, NY - Water Mill Modern Farmhouse Masterpiece - Built in 2022 This stunning Modern Farmhouse, built in 2022, is located in prime Water Mill North, off of Head of Pond Road, across from Mill Pond. There are five king-sized bedrooms, 7 full baths and one half bath. The sun-flooded main floor includes a soaring two-story entrance foyer, high ceilings, state of the art kitchen with breakfast area, Thermador appliances, built-in Thermador wine column, a large walk in pantry and open central dining area. The living room has a masonry fireplace and sliding doors to the south-facing bluestone patio. There is a separate formal dining room with shiplap trim, a spacious first floor primary suite with high ceilings and its own en-suite bathroom, a full sized pool bathroom, a powder room, a spacious mud room, and oversized attached two car garage. Sliding glass doors lead to a large two-level bluestone patio and 20x40 heated gunite pool with water feature. The second floor includes a large primary suite with private balcony overlooking the pool and bluestone patio. Its en-suite bathroom has a floating bathtub, double sinks, radiant heated floors, and oversized walk-in shower. Each additional bedroom is en-suite with its own private bathroom. All closets are custom built and there is a separate bonus room. The partially finished basement includes a full bathroom. There is an additional 1900 square feet of unfinished basement, with high ceilings and four windows that can be easily finished and customized. A large, level driveway from Head of Pond Road leads to the attached garage, bluestone front walkway and stately covered front entrance. Mature landscaping provides complete privacy and an estate-like feeling to the property.

$5,300,000 - Water Mill, NY

940 Deerfield Road Water Mill, NY - This six bedroom, five bath compound is set on a sun-drenched acre adjacent to 80 acres of forever-preserved land in the wide open farm fields of Water Mill. Stylishly executed and beautifully maintained by an eminent build and design team, both the main and guest houses radiate authentic farmhouse character with a sophisticated spin. The double-height entertaining room with its dramatic stone fireplace flows to the dining area and modern chef's kitchen anchored by ceruse oak cabinetry that echoes the hand hewn post-and-beam structural elements and wide plank oak floors throughout the home. A first floor guest suite and a cozy den with a fireplace complete this level while upstairs are the ensuite primary suite with vaulted ceilings and marble-accented bathroom and two guest rooms that share a sunny hall bath. A mezzanine overlooks the main floor and its double-story window that celebrates the outdoor amenities: expansive stone patios, heated 20x45-foot gunite pool with retractable cover, outdoor shower, sprawling lawns and the sunset views beyond. The separate two-bedroom, two-bath guest house has its own kitchen, gym and garage with an electric vehicle charger. This property is a gem in itself and also has plans (available separately) for an as-of-right expansion to over 7,000 square feet of above-ground living area. All this, very centrally located mere moments to Water Mill, Southampton and Bridgehampton and their sparkling ocean beaches beyond.

$5,300,000 - Water Mill, NY

17 & 19 Magnolia Drive Water Mill, NY - An exciting new community is taking shape in the heart of Water Mill offering the ultimate in luxury and convenience, with classic Hamptons style in an easy-to-maintain, manageable environment. Watermill Crossing provides village living with full services and amenities, in homes inspired by quintessential Hamptons architecture. Materials and finishes of the highest quality are a hallmark of Watermill Crossing and no detail has been overlooked in curating this best-in-class living experience. Sited on manicured 6.4 acres, this 2-story townhome features 4,918 +/- sq. ft., 8 bedrooms and 8 full baths, and an attached 2-car garage. The light-filled open main floor living spaces flow easily among a living room with fireplace, dining area, and eat-in kitchen with top-of-the-line stainless steel appliances and quartz countertops, and island seating. Interiors are pristine and ready for contemporary luxury living in the Hamptons. Below, the unfinished lower level adds another 631 +/- sq. ft. of space that awaits your final touches. The community includes a centrally located clubhouse and features a gym center, great room, food prep area, and wet bar. Outdoors, amidst a large stone patio sits an oversized gunite pool and separate spa. Located in the heart of Watermill Village with the ocean beaches just a few miles away, this is a great opportunity to join the charming Watermill Crossing community. The complete terms are in an Offering Plan available from Sponsor. File No. CD21-0268.

$4,495,000 - Water Mill, NY

61 Lower Seven Ponds Road Water Mill, NY - 61 Lower Seven Ponds Road, a hidden gem in the heart of Water Mill where luxury living meets unspoiled natural beauty. Set on nearly 9 acres of lush, parklike grounds, this extraordinary estate offers a rare combination of serenity, space, and potential in one of the Hamptons' most sought-after enclaves. The main residence blends timeless charm with endless opportunity. Currently featuring generous living areas, a luminous solarium that invites nature indoors, sunroom, den, and a sauna. The home also includes three unfinished rooms above the garage-offering the potential to expand the total living space to approximately 6,000 square feet. Whether you're dreaming of additional bedrooms, a gym, an artist's studio, or a home theater, the possibilities are as expansive as the landscape itself. Adding to the allure, an adorable, fully renovated guest cottage sits gracefully on the property. Ideal for hosting guests, or as a private workspace, the cottage complements the main home while offering its own stylish retreat. Outdoors, the estate is a true recreational paradise. Wide open lawns are framed by mature trees and landscaping, providing both seclusion and elegance. Nature lovers and sports enthusiasts alike will be captivated by the setting-whether it's boating, archery, fishing, or hunting, the property is tailored to a range of outdoor passions. In warmer months, enjoy bird watching by day and tranquil sunsets over the western-facing pond by evening. In the winter, the landscape transforms into your personal ice-skating haven. This exceptional Water Mill offering is more than just a residence-it's a lifestyle. Whether you're seeking a peaceful escape, a legacy compound, or a canvas to bring your architectural vision to life, 61 Lower Seven Ponds Road delivers the ultimate in Hamptons living. Architectural rendering shown is for illustrative purposes only, designed by Christopher Arelt, Architect, AIA. Nautilus Architects. Additional information about this design/ build opportunity available. Listing ID: 916751

$3,995,000 - Water Mill, NY

359 Noyac Path Water Mill, NY - This designer-curated Hamptons retreat offers contemporary luxury and timeless elegance. Architectural ingenuity and inspired design make this Hamptons home truly impressive, immediately ready for elevated entertaining and luxury living. On close to an acre in Water Mill, surrounded by reserves with views, this sophisticated 3-level home has 3,400 +/- sq. ft. of living space, 4 bedrooms, 3 full baths, attached 2-car garage, and heated gunite pool; plus an expansive lower level and room for a pool house. The natural beauty of Eastern and Western exposure overlooking hundreds of acres of preserved land cannot be overstated, and they will remain forever protected. From the exterior, the home strikes a perfect balance between contemporary and traditional style, with dark charcoal cedar siding, a zinc roof, and an aluminum-wrapped steel entry door. Interiors are bright and open, highlighted by slate flooring, double-height ceilings, clerestory windows and walls of glass. Designer details-including premium curated lighting and Palupe wood trim-are seen and felt throughout the home. At the central focal point, is a custom spiral staircase made of steel, bamboo, and tempered wooden banister, which appears to float above a dramatic double-height view of the rear courtyard. On one wing, a custom dual-sided fireplace separates the dining area from the living room, which overlooks acres of bucolic reserves. A wall of windows and 5 sturdy, stay-open glass doors invite the outdoors in, with easy access for dining al fresco and sun lounging in the backyard. Opposite the staircase, the eat-in kitchen matches beauty and performance with professional appliances, granite center island, and custom Bendheim glass cabinets. The first level is completed by a tiled-bath, first floor bedroom, office/den, and access to the attached 2-car garage. Upstairs, find three bedrooms, including the primary, each with double-height ceilings. The ensuite primary is a luxurious haven, wrapped in light and sunset reserve views and equipped with a private balcony patio, wood-burning fireplace, walk-in closet, and ensuite bath with a glass-lined shower, a Japanese soaking tub, water closet, and dual vanity. Additionally, two guestrooms, one overlooking reserve and another with an attached office, share a full bath. The home's L-shape design shields the rear grounds from outside elements-without blocking the sun-creating a calming courtyard with slate patio, 16'x54' heated gunite pool, garden, and a lush lawn dotted with mature specimen trees. Find peace and privacy at home with elevated Hamptons living always close at hand with nearby Water Mill, Bridgehampton, and Sag Harbor Villages with boutique shops and dining - plus, world-famous white sandy ocean beaches.

$3,875,000 - Water Mill, NY

12 Bob White Drive Water Mill, NY - Luxurious Water Mill Retreat: Welcome to this stunning traditional shingled home nestled in the serene hamlet of Water Mill. Spanning an impressive 4,750 square feet of livable space, this residence offers the perfect blend of luxury and comfort across three thoughtfully designed levels. The home features five well-appointed bedrooms and four and a half bathrooms, including two main suites with elegant marble en-suite baths conveniently located on each of the first two floors. As you step inside, you are welcomed by soaring ceilings. The natural light floods the space through abundant windows that complement the new wide white oak hardwood floors. The open plan seamlessly connects the light filled living room to the new chef’s kitchen that is outfitted with high-end Wolf and Subzero appliances. The adjacent dining room, which comfortably seats fourteen, opens onto a beautiful mahogany wood upper deck that is perfect for entertaining against the lush backdrop. The lower level includes a substantial 600-foot media room boasting 9-foot ceilings, a bedroom and bathroom, dedicated office space and an extra space that can be a playroom or gym. Environmentally conscious features include solar panels connected to the electric grid and a heat pump, making this home both sustainable and energy efficient. Outside you will discover meticulously maintained grounds featuring a heated pool with expansive sundecks and a charming gazebo. This property’s location on a peaceful cul-de-sac offers the perfect balance of privacy and convenience, with easy access to the vibrant villages and pristine beaches that define the Hamptons lifestyle.

$3,875,000 - Water Mill, NY

248 Blank Lane Water Mill, NY - Down a long private driveway 359+', sits a charming split level ranch, with amazing views and privacy overlooking 100acres of farmland. The interior house boasts 3504, sf above ground and a partially finished basement/rec room. The 3 primary suits are all in different wings of the house offering the most amount of privacy. The unground vinyl pool is salt based and heated. outdoor shower and 1/4 bbc. Buy as is or make it your own., Additional information: Appearance:good,Interior Features:Guest Quarters,Lr/Dr,Marble Bath

Water Mill, New York listings for sale

End of list

There were no properties mapped for this search