Tannersville, New York listings for sale

​
$2,999,124 - Tannersville, NY
863 Route 25 Tannersville, NY - PRICE IMPROVEMENT!! Your chance to own the pinnacle of luxury in Greene County NY. Take a ride in the scenic mountains near Tannersville NY and you will have the opportunity to wander down a magical drive that will transport you back in time to the Golden Age of The Catskills, and to Caddam Hill. Once the home of the famous actress Maude Adams, you can hear echoes of a time gone by from every corner of the estate's 31 acres, which are comprised of majestic mountain views, an extensive trail system that passes a spring-fed pond, and lovely sparkling streams. The estate's acreage offers an abundance of natural beauty and privacy for your exclusive enjoyment; but, meander among the trees, you'll also connect to the Mountain Top Arboretum (156 acres of protected land) and Hunter Foundation (136 acres) which are both adjacent to this property, as is the well-known artist and writer's retreat, Onteora Club - where Maude Adams once mounted theatricals with friends. The warmth and charm that envelopes you when you walk through the front door of Caddam Hill follows throughout the home. Enter the stunning great room, take in the original woodwork, beams & gleaming oak floors - the stone fireplace will surely capture your attention until you look through the antique windows at the spectacular mountain views. Breathtaking sunsets can be enjoyed from every room on the south side of the house and from the expansive wrap-around deck. This beautiful, historic property from the 1900's has been updated for modern comfort and practicality in every way imaginable, without losing any of its prodigious original character. If the walls could talk the stories would amaze you. Standout spaces include a well-appointed chef's kitchen, billiards room, media room, gym, a cozy bar, and elegant primary suite with fireplace. Caddam Hill is convenient to the many attractions in the vibrant 4-season Catskills community: Kaaterskill Falls, Twilight Park, Hunter Mountain Ski Resort, the trails of Catskill Park, Colonial Country Club, Colgate Lake, the charming Village of Tannersville, performing arts venues, restaurants (it's a mere 0.2 miles to The Deer Mountain Inn), and area festivals are just of few of the nearby notables. - WELCOME TO CADDAM HILL.
1903 | 6 | 5 | 8,500 sqft.
​
$1,300,000 - Tannersville, NY
170 Route 23C Tannersville, NY - Opportunity knocks! Two new custom built homes on two approved lots --3.07 acres and .83 acre --to be built--each 1.3. Buyer can select their design from hundreds of designs or bring their own customized design --see-: naturalelementhomes.com. Square footage can be increased or decreased.Price can be increased or decreased based on the selected customization. Buyer will meet with esteemed builder to customize design. Construction financing by buyer to convert into mortgage. Photo displayed is an example and is not the house to be built---unless the purchaser selects this design. Heat: oil, geothermal or propane--selected by buyer.Prime-rare-amazing---location opportunity.A short walk to the beautiful, quaint and colorful Village of Tannersville.Close to nearby slopes and the Onteora Club. Rear lot: view of stream. Note: existing house to be removed. Additional Information: HeatingFuel:Oil Above Ground,ParkingFeatures:2 Car Attached,
2025 | 3 | 4 | 2,800 sqft.
​
$899,000 - Tannersville, NY
6424 Route 23A Tannersville, NY - Welcome to Casa Solara — a custom-built California Mission-style masterpiece nestled on over 14 private wooded acres in the heart of Tannersville. Just moments from Main Street and beloved Hunter Mountain, this one-of-a-kind 4-bedroom, 3-bath estate offers the perfect blend of mountain serenity, timeless design, and walkable village charm. As you wind up the private, wooded driveway, the trees part and the land opens up to reveal a breathtaking sight — Casa Solara, glowing with warmth and history. Anchored by a dramatic locally sourced granite fireplace and crowned by the home's centerpiece — a striking gallery room filled with natural light — every inch of this 3,600+ square foot retreat was thoughtfully crafted by the original owners with intention, soul, and vision. From intimate family memories to grand entertaining spaces, this home exudes a sense of both legacy and possibility. Whether you're curled up fireside after a ski day, gathering under the soaring ceilings of the gallery room, or sipping coffee with mountain views just outside your door, Casa Solara invites you to slow down and savor. Located just steps from Tannersville's charming Main Street — with restaurants, a grocery store, a golf course, and year-round festivities — and offering front-row views of Hunter Mountain's iconic slopes, this property is the ultimate upstate retreat or full-time sanctuary.
1980 | 4 | 3 | 3,640 sqft.
​
$899,000 - Tannersville, NY
6424 Route 23A Tannersville, NY - Welcome to Casa Solara — a custom-built California Mission-style masterpiece nestled on over 14 private wooded acres in the heart of Tannersville. Just moments from Main Street and beloved Hunter Mountain, this one-of-a-kind 4-bedroom, 3-bath estate offers the perfect blend of mountain serenity, timeless design, and walkable village charm. As you wind up the private, wooded driveway, the trees part and the land opens up to reveal a breathtaking sight — Casa Solara, glowing with warmth and history. Anchored by a dramatic locally sourced granite fireplace and crowned by the home's centerpiece — a striking gallery room filled with natural light — every inch of this 3,600+ square foot retreat was thoughtfully crafted by the original owners with intention, soul, and vision. From intimate family memories to grand entertaining spaces, this home exudes a sense of both legacy and possibility. Whether you're curled up fireside after a ski day, gathering under the soaring ceilings of the gallery room, or sipping coffee with mountain views just outside your door, Casa Solara invites you to slow down and savor. Located just steps from Tannersville's charming Main Street — with restaurants, a grocery store, a golf course, and year-round festivities — and offering front-row views of Hunter Mountain's iconic slopes, this property is the ultimate upstate retreat or full-time sanctuary.
1980 | 4 | 3 | 3,640 sqft.
​
$800,000 - Tannersville, NY
170 Route 23C Tannersville, NY - Two new homes to be built.Select from hundreds of designs or bring your customized design.From1000 to 6000 square feet.Prices to be determined.Estimate: $800,000---2,000,000--depending on the design.Lots are approved by the DEP and the Town of Hunter.Lots are: 3.07 and .83 acres.Short distance to beautiful, quaint and colorful Village of Tannersville--Town of Hunter.Construction financing by the buyer to convert into mortgage.Close to nearby slopes and the Onteora Club.Rear lot--view of stream. Mountain views.Wooded and private. Call for details: 914-879-8447.NOTE: photos are sample designs from hundreds of available designs.See over 400 designs at: naturalelementhomes.com.
2025 | 3 | 4 | 2,800 sqft.
​
$735,000 - Tannersville, NY
73 Fern Ridge Rd Tannersville, NY - Your Dream Mountain Retreat Awaits!Discover this beautifully renovated 4-bedroom, 3-bathroom home nestled on a serene 2.5-acre property, just 10 minutes from Hunter Mountain Resort. With 2,370 square feet of thoughtfully designed living space, this home blends modern comfort with rustic charm, making it the perfect getaway or full-time residence.Step into the expansive great room, where soaring ceilings and natural light create a warm, inviting atmosphere. The open-concept kitchen and dining area, complete with modern finishes, are ideal for entertaining friends and family. Downstairs, a finished basement features a game room, perfect for endless fun and relaxation.Unwind outdoors on the spacious deck, soak in the private hot tub, or take in the tranquility of the surrounding nature. The home also offers a cozy sitting room for quiet moments, an attached garage for convenience, and a long driveway that ensures ultimate privacy.Set on a generous lot with mature trees and mountain views, this property is a rare gem, providing easy access to skiing, hiking, and all the outdoor adventures Hunter Mountain has to offer.Don't miss your chance to own this secluded haven in the heart of the Catskills! Schedule your showing today!The house has a successful short term rental history. Be sure to check out the virtual tour.
1990 | 4 | 3 | 2,730 sqft.
​
$596,000 - Tannersville, NY
6899 Route 23A Tannersville, NY - A true GEM! Listed below Full Market Value! Perfectly located house between Hunter and Tannersville with amazing views, beautiful 1.5 acres back yard bordering creek is ready for the new lucky owner! The house is in excellent condition and offers: new roof (2024), new furnace, new hot water heater on demand, new stucco on the chimney, large oversized deck, 2 wood burning fireplaces, two kitchens and two meters allows you to use and rent in the same time...unbelievable income potential, both apartments have separate entrances. The 5 bedrooms, 4 bathrooms and spacious living rooms give unlimited possibilities to the new owner who can rent and enjoy the house in the same time. Owners lives in the house and advance notice for viewing is required. Don't wait, make it yours before the summer arrives.
1993 | 5 | 4 | 2,880 sqft.
​
$394,000 - Tannersville, NY
51 Grays Lane Tannersville, NY - Welcome to the heart of Tannersvillea home that's more than a place, it's a feeling.In a village where the Catskills meet creativity, where mountain air mixes with the buzz of Main Street, this fully furnished retreat offers the perfect blend of getaway and gathering place. Whether you're seeking a year-round residence or a weekend escape, this is your chance to own a piece of Tannersville's charm.Tucked just off the main strip, close to shops, dining, and the vibrant arts scene, yet set back with its own private rhythmbordered by trees and a gentle creekyou'll feel a world away without missing a beat. Imagine unwinding on your deck, stars glittering above, fire pit glowing, and the sound of the creek your evening soundtrack.Inside, the home delivers four bedrooms and two baths, beautifully updated with hardwood and tile floors. The kitchen flows seamlessly into the living room, perfect for entertaining, with sliding glass doors opening to that dreamy deck. The spa-style bathroom with Jacuzzi tub invites you to soak the day away. Upstairs, three bedrooms and a second bath await, plus an expansive bonus room with skylightsideal for stargazing, hosting guests, or creating your own studio or game space.Step out your door and into everything Tannersville offers: live music, theater, boutique shopping, dining, hiking trails, skiing at Hunter Mountain, kayaking, ice skating, summer concerts, and festivalsall within minutes.Move-in ready, fully furnished, and beautifully positioned in the center of it allthis is more than a home; it's your Catskills experience.Ready to write your next chapter in Tannersville? Reach out today and claim your front-row seat to it all.
1910 | 4 | 2 | 2,126 sqft.
​
$325,000 - Tannersville, NY
107 Spruce Street Tannersville, NY - Check out this delightful 3-bedroom, 1.5-bath home in the heart of Tannersville, perfect for anyone seeking a peaceful retreat or a vibrant village lifestyle. Situated on a generous .68-acre lot, this home offers a flat, spacious yard with a wooded backdrop, creating a private oasis right in your backyard.Inside, this charming village home offers a warm and inviting interior, starting with an updated kitchen featuring modern appliances, ready for all your culinary adventures. The kitchen seamlessly opens to the back deck, perfect for summer BBQs and outdoor entertaining. Adjacent to the kitchen is a convenient separate laundry room, adding to the home's functionality. The living room, featuring a cozy gas fireplace, provides a comfortable space for relaxation and gatherings. The dining room is ideal for enjoying meals with family and friends. You'll also find a newly renovated full bathroom on the main level, thoughtfully updated with modern finishes. Upstairs, there are three well-appointed bedrooms and a convenient half bath, making this home a great starter option or a wonderful place to host guests. The home is connected to municipal water and sewer, a convenient bonus for easy living.The village of Tannersville is known for its welcoming community and scenic beauty. This home is within walking distance to the park and Rip Van Winkle Lake, providing endless outdoor activities. The nearby rail trail is perfect for hiking and biking enthusiasts.Additional features include a storage shed and an old garage, offering plenty of space for your tools, toys, or the potential to create a workshop or outdoor bar. The property also hosts an old pad site, ideal for adding an ADU or tiny home, expanding your living or rental potential.Enjoy your mornings and evenings on the charming back deck or the inviting front porch, both perfect for relaxation and taking in the seasonal views. Whether you're looking for a starter home, a second home, a ski house, or a country getaway, this Tannersville gem is as charming as they come. Don't miss out on this perfect opportunityschedule a private tour before it's gone!
1920 | 3 | 2 | 1,146 sqft.