Garden City New York homes for sale starting at Fifty Thousand Dollars

$1,549,000 - Garden City, NY

141 Tullamore Garden City, NY - Enjoy timeless charm and character in this beloved Garden City estates home. The traditional brick colonial offers four bedrooms & three full baths. Generously sized rooms provide an inviting atmosphere. An impressive 2246 square feet of living space designed for comfort and style. The traditional center hall colonial with foyer entry shows a gracious living room, a large formal dining room and kitchen. The French door sliders off the sunporch lead to a fabulous patio. Interior highlights of the home’s elegance include twin Bay windows, Marvin true divided lite replacements throughout, built in corner cabinetry, cove moldings and millwork that reflect its history, A grand field stone wood burning fireplace compliment the large living room, and lovely double circular flow on the main floor. The lower level offers large recreation room with original faux field stone fireplace plus large laundry, mechanical work room. The backyard makes for a relaxing respite to enjoy al fresco everything with family and friends. Walk up third floor offers a huge spacious storage attic. 2 car detached garage. Situated in a prime sought-after Garden City Estates neighborhood. This property is a wonderful opportunity to make your own. Location, space, character and charm, this home is not to be missed.

$1,499,000 - Garden City, NY

114 Wickham Road Garden City, NY - Charming Colonial in Prime Location with Spacious Layout Welcome to this beautifully maintained Colonial home, ideally situated in the middle of a quiet, tree-lined street. Offering timeless charm and modern comfort, this residence features 3 generously sized bedrooms and 3 full bathrooms, providing ample space for residents and guests. Step inside to find a formal living room with a classic wood-burning fireplace—perfect for cozy evenings—alongside a bright formal dining room ideal for entertaining. The full finished basement offers flexible space for a media room, home office, or gym, while the full unfinished attic presents an opportunity for future expansion or storage. Enjoy the serenity of a private backyard, perfect for gardening, relaxing, or summer gatherings. Located in a sought-after neighborhood close to schools, parks, and local amenities, this home combines character, comfort, and convenience. Don't miss the chance to make this exceptional Colonial your forever home! When you arrive, you can't help to sing the classic song "Our House" by Madness when you see that this house is in the middle of the street.

$1,399,999 - Garden City, NY

1 Prospect Avenue Garden City, NY - Nestled in the highly desirable town of Garden City, a stunning Colonial at 1 Prospect Avenue awaits. This beautifully maintained 4 Bedroom, 2.5 Bathroom home blends classic charm with tasteful modern updates. The first floor layout includes a charming 1940's foyer right as you walk through the door. A newly renovated kitchen that features sleek stainless steel appliances, Quartz counter tops and a gas cooking range, ideal for home chefs and entertaining. Throughout the home, you’ll find rich hardwood floors that enhance its warmth and timeless appeal. A spacious dining room and a living room with a fireplace that adds to the inviting atmosphere. Included on this level is a half bathroom powder room and three seasons room at the back of the home, perfect for relaxing and enjoying views of the property. Upstairs, the second floor offers four generously sized bedrooms and two full bathrooms. The primary suite is a true retreat, featuring great closet space and a private en-suite bathroom. Each additional bedroom offers ample space and natural light, making it ideal for guests or a home office. The basement is currently used as a den/living room space as well as storage and a utility room. Very dynamic space as it has an exterior walk out entrance that leads to the backyard. Outside, the home is set on two generous lots with street frontage on Prospect, Meadow, and Clinton. The meticulously landscaped yard includes an attached two-car garage and an additional playhouse/storage structure. With proper permits, the second lot offers exciting potential to build another home, add an inground pool/pool house, or create an accessory dwelling unit (ADU). Driveway has space unobstructed parking for 5 vehicles. Located within the renowned Garden City School District and close to parks, transit, and village amenities, this home presents a rare opportunity to own a piece of Garden City’s history with space to grow. Blocks away from LIRR Country Life Station.

$1,399,000 - Garden City, NY

217 Whitehall Boulevard Garden City, NY - Built In 1959, This Home Is Available For The First Time! 2500 SqFt Expanded Cape In The Desirable Estates Section Of The Village Offers 6 Bedrooms And 3 Full Baths. Spacious Great Room With Fireplace, Formal Dining Room, Kitchen, Den, Bedroom, Office And Full Bath Complete The First Floor. Second Floor Offers 5 Generously Sized Bedrooms And 2 Full Baths. Basement Is Unfinished With Plenty Of Storage Space. 2 Car Detached Garage. 9600 SqFt Lot. Convenient To LIRR Merillon Avenue Train Station. The Possibilities Are Endless For The Buyer To Make It Their Own. Home Is Being Sold AS-IS.

$1,398,000 - Garden City, NY

120 Lincoln Street Garden City, NY - This charming 3 bedroom 1.5 bath home is a quintessential Garden City Colonial. Located midblock in the Western section conveniently close to schools, parks and two train lines. Surrounded by a well manicured lawn with a large 2 car garage and a shady deck for outdoor gatherings. Inside the home you will find hardwood floors throughout, high ceilings and sunlit rooms. The entryway offers a powder room and a study with glass doors for privacy. The large living room leads to a bright, casual dining room and a fresh white kitchen with marble countertops, farm sink and breakfast bar. The open floorplan flows beautifully and is a natural venue for entertaining. On the second floor, there are 3 bright and generous bedrooms, a full bath, and a staircase to the attic for easy access to additional storage. Downstairs you will find a spacious den with enlarged windows, a generous walk in closet, laundry room and bonus room perfect for an office or gym - and more. This home has been meticulously and lovingly maintained with many upgrades, including natural gas, new windows, air with multiple zones, sprinkler system, alarm system, and new appliances. The extra bonus: Low Taxes. This one will go fast!

$1,389,000 - Garden City, NY

22 Hudson Road Garden City, NY - Beautifully renovated split-level home nestled in Garden City’s charming “Little Connecticut” neighborhood. This move-in ready residence offers an open-concept layout with vaulted ceilings, detailed millwork, and a cozy fireplace in the living room. The modern kitchen seamlessly flows into the dining area, perfect for entertaining. Upstairs features three spacious bedrooms, including a primary suite with a private en suite bath, plus a fully updated hall bathroom with a double vanity. The lower level offers a bright den, convenient mudroom space, and direct access to a two-car garage with ample storage. A finished basement with high ceilings provides additional recreation space. The fully fenced backyard features turf landscaping, ideal for low-maintenance outdoor enjoyment. Located near Nassau Haven Park, the NHP train station, and top-rated Garden City elementary schools.

$1,385,000 - Garden City, NY

173 Willow Street Garden City, NY - Perfectly situated on a quiet tree lined street, this beautiful colonial boasts an abundant amount of living and entertaining space including 5 bedrooms and 3.5 bathrooms. The home features an entrance foyer, a sun-drenched living room with a fireplace, an elegant dining room, a beautiful updated eat-in gourmet kitchen with custom cabinetry and stainless-steel appliances and a powder room. A separate first floor bedroom or office serviced by a full bathroom and a cozy den room complete this level. The second floor boasts a spacious primary bedroom and 3 additional nicely sized bedrooms that are serviced by 2 full bathrooms. The basement recreation room, coupled with the fenced private backyard setting with mature plantings and a brick patio, provides an ideal setting for entertaining. The home is conveniently located near the school, park, shopping, and the Country Life Press LIRR station. The location, size, and meticulous condition make this a truly exceptional value and the perfect place to call home!

$1,379,000 - Garden City, NY

42 Huntington Road Garden City, NY - This fieldstone Colonial is located in the highly desirable Mott section and is situated on a 65x125 lot.. Near to schools, town, parks, shopping and highways. This home is very spacious and has been meticulously maintained.

$1,290,000 - Garden City, NY

2 Wyatt Road Garden City, NY - Surprisingly spacious and full of charm, this stone and brick center-hall Colonial is located in Garden City’s Mott Section. Thoughtfully maintained and brimming with character, this home offers the perfect blend of timeless design and modern comfort. Inside, gleaming hardwood floors flow throughout, beginning with an inviting living room featuring custom built-in cabinetry, a classic bay window, and a cozy wood-burning fireplace. The formal dining room sets the stage for memorable gatherings, while the renovated custom Bisulk kitchen—with stylish finishes, a breakfast nook, and ample storage—makes everyday living a joy. A versatile den or home office, convenient powder room, and a sun-filled family room addition complete the main level. Upstairs, the primary suite offers its own fireplace and private bath. Two additional generously sized bedrooms and a full hall bath provide plenty of space for family or guests. Step outside to a generously sized lot with a private, fenced area ideal for relaxing or entertaining. The attached one-car garage adds convenience, while central air conditioning ensures year-round comfort. Located close to schools, parks, transportation and Garden City’s vibrant downtown, this home truly has it all. Don’t miss this rare opportunity—schedule your private showing today!

$1,159,000 - Garden City, NY

181 Washington Avenue Garden City, NY - Situated in the sought-after Mott Section of Garden City, this beautifully updated colonial is in impeccable, move-in-ready condition. The sun-filled living room welcomes you with a cozy fireplace, seamlessly connecting to an elegant formal dining room—ideal for both everyday living and entertaining. The updated kitchen boasts crisp white cabinetry, stainless-steel appliances, and a clean, modern aesthetic. A full bathroom and a charming sunroom with French doors that open to a brick patio complete the main level. Upstairs, you'll find a spacious primary bedroom with custom built-in closets, a beautifully renovated full bathroom, and two additional well-proportioned bedrooms. The newly finished basement offers a generous recreation space perfect for entertaining, a playroom, or a home office. Amenities include central air conditioning and in-ground sprinklers. Ideally located near top-rated schools, town, parks, shopping, and the Mineola LIRR station, this home offers convenience, style, and exceptional value. With its thoughtful layout and pristine condition this is truly a place you'll be proud to call home.

Garden City, New York listings for sale

End of list

There were no properties mapped for this search