Bay Shore, New York listings for sale

​
$599,999 - Bay Shore, NY
1125 Reilly Street Bay Shore, NY - Welcome to the Baywood section of Bay Shore! This well-built home offers plenty of potential and is filled with natural light, with beautiful oak floors throughout. The second floor provides generous storage, and the full basement offers room to expand or customize additional living space. Recent updates include a roof replaced within the last 10 years with a 40-year warranty, a 7-year-old oil tank, and a brand-new boiler installed in March 2025, making this home not only solid but secure for years to come. The large backyard features an Ester Williams semi-inground aluminum-walled pool with a hopper bottom ranging from 3 to 7 feet deep. Although it hasn't been opened in a few years, it was properly closed; the pool is being sold as-is with no warranties. A built-in brick BBQ with insert adds to the outdoor charm. The cesspool was redone within the last 10 years with two rings and an overflow, located near the backyard sheds. Inside, the dining room was creatively converted from half of the original garage, with the remaining space used for laundry and storage. This is a solid, comfortable home with great features and room to make it your own.
1954 | 4 | 2 | 1,866 sqft.
​
$599,990 - Bay Shore, NY
1609 N Thompson Drive Bay Shore, NY - Stately Colonial with Exceptional Features! This elegant four bedroom, three full bath Colonial offers the perfect blend of comfort, function, and charm. The home boasts soaring cathedral ceilings, hardwood floors, and recessed lighting. Enjoy a kitchen with granite counters, formal dining room, and formal living room, ideal for entertaining. Additional living space includes a den/playroom and an enclosed sunroom, perfect for year-round enjoyment. The primary suite features a large walk-in closet. A pellet stove adds warmth and character, while the pull-down attic provides ample storage. Outdoor living is a dream with a built-in gas barbecue, a deck combining wood and Trex materials, and a gas generator for peace of mind. The home also includes a laundry room, solar panels for energy efficiency, and so much more!
1953 | 4 | 3 | 2,369 sqft.
​
$599,990 - Bay Shore, NY
257 New Hampshire Avenue Bay Shore, NY - Welcome to 257 New Hampshire centrally located between Bay Shore and Brentwood and close to all major transportation and main Highways. This home features Three bedrooms on the main level with its own private master bath, Formal living room with gleaming hardwood floors, formal dining room and breakfast nook and a large Den perfect for entertaining. Priced right for a quick sale don't miss this opportunity
1965 | 3 | 3 | 1,200 sqft.
​
$599,000 - Bay Shore, NY
1519 Saint Louis Avenue Bay Shore, NY - Spacious L shape Farm Ranch on large property located in Islip school district. Home has hardwood floors, primary bedroom with bath, basement and walk in attic. A wonderful home to enjoy with lots of potential. Priced to sell. Additional information: Appearance:Excellent
1969 | 5 | 2 | 1,995 sqft.
​
$599,000 - Bay Shore, NY
1760 Manatuck Boulevard Bay Shore, NY - Welcome to Your Dream Home! Step into this stunning designer residence, meticulously crafted with luxurious finishes and thoughtful details. Discover the Crown molding and fine finishes for a touch of elegance. Energy-efficient windows for comfort and savings. Gourmet kitchen with quartz countertops and high-end stainless steel appliances. Potential mother/daughter setup with separate entrance. Formal Living room with floor-to-ceiling luxury. Spacious primary suite with high ceiling, and expansive closet. Two additional luxurious bedrooms and large bathroom. Smart home features with alarm system. Retreat to your own private paradise, complete with a luxurious kitchen area. Don't miss this rare gem! Schedule a viewing and fall in love.
1927 | 3 | 2 | 1,368 sqft.
​
$595,000 - Bay Shore, NY
78 Brentwood Street Bay Shore, NY - Charming ranch house in the heart of Bay Shore. Living room, Eat in kitchen, Dining area, Five bedrooms, Two full baths, Full finished basement, Laundry room, Central air, Gas heating, Hardwood floors, Summer kitchen, Two storage sheds, Extended driveway. All on beautiful park-like grounds.
1960 | 5 | 2 | 1,386 sqft.
​
$589,999 - Bay Shore, NY
1251 Udall Road Bay Shore, NY - Welcome to this charming ranch-style home offering a perfect blend of comfort and versatility. The main floor features a spacious living room, a formal dining room, a functional kitchen, 3 comfortable bedrooms, and a full bathroom. The fully finished basement adds even more living space with 2 additional bedrooms, a full bathroom, and a separate outside entrance, ideal for extended family or guest accommodations. Conveniently located near local amenities, parks, and transportation. A must-see opportunity!
1960 | 3 | 2 | 966 sqft.
​
$589,900 - Bay Shore, NY
760 Spur Drive N Bay Shore, NY - Great Home, Renovated Kitchen, 2 Baths, Cozy home, & Large Yard Home Larger than what it appears
1955 | 4 | 3 | 1,200 sqft.
​
$585,000 - Bay Shore, NY
1551 Lincoln Boulevard Bay Shore, NY - Charming 3 Bedroom Cape Cod on Oversized Property with Attached Garage and 5 Car Driveway! Living Room features a Wood Burning Fireplace. Kitchen has been Updated and Opens to a Dining Room with Sliding Doors Leading to the Backyard. Full Updated Bath. Primary Bedroom was originally 2 Bedrooms and opened to make one large King Size Bedroom. The First Floor has Hardwood Floors. The Second Floor has Two Bedrooms. The Basement is Finished with a Bath & Laundry Area. The Oversize Yard has an Above Ground Heated Salt Water Pool and Shed. The yard is all vinyl fenced in with a 20 x 20 Paver Patio ***There are Solar Panels that are leased and the contract is paid in full. This is transferable to the buyer. There are 20 years left and the company name is IGS ENERGY SOLAR. The electric bill is approx. $23 per month!! Seller will provide copies of his electric bills. Electric Service is 200 AMPS.
1957 | 3 | 2 | 1,929 sqft.
​
$577,900 - Bay Shore, NY
78 Brentwood Street Bay Shore, NY - Charming ranch house in the heart of Bay Shore. Living room, Eat in kitchen, Dining area, Five bedrooms, Two full baths, Full finished basement, Laundry room, Central air, Gas heating, Hardwood floors, Summer kitchen, Two storage sheds, Extended driveway. All on beautiful park-like grounds.
1960 | 5 | 2 | 1,386 sqft.