Bay Shore, New York listings for sale

​
$745,000 - Bay Shore, NY
209 Pleasant Drive Bay Shore, NY - Come experience this spacious 4 bedroom, 3.5 bath Townhome located in the Mystic Oaks Community. This beautifully designed home features a spacious living room, dining room and an updated kitchen complete with granite countertops, stainless steel appliances and ample cabinetry. Generously sized bedrooms including a primary suite with a private en-suite bath. With 3 full bedrooms and a convenient full bath on the second level. The fully finished basement has egress windows and full bath offers versatile additional living space and ample storage. Enjoy the outdoors with a charming front porch and a backyard featuring a paver patio and a built in BBQ area-perfect for entertaining. Mystic Oaks offers fantastic amenities including a clubhouse and park, making this the ideal place to call home.
2001 | 4 | 4 | 2,542 sqft.
​
$725,000 - Bay Shore, NY
37 21St Avenue Bay Shore, NY - Welcome to this Young & Fabulous Wide-line High-Ranch. This Spacious Home is situated on a quiet mid-block location, moments to everything! Offering 2,500+ sq ft with Plenty of Room for Mom AND Mom-in-Law, featuring 3 separate entrances. ALL above ground! Inviting Grand 2-Story Chandelier Entry Foyer leads you to the Upper Living Space. From the Moment you enter, you know you are not in your "typical" High-Ranch! This 1990 Built Wide-Line HR offers a Larger & more Spacious Living Space all around! Bright Open Living Room with Abundant Natural Light, Formal Dining Room w/Window Views to Picturesque Yard. Large Granite Chef's Kitchen w/ Modern Glass Mosaic Backsplash & Newer Cabinets. Exit to Upper Trex Deck for Delightful Morning Coffee, Lunch, Dinner or simple afternoon relaxation on your Upper Deck. Primary King Size Bedroom features large double closet and walk-in closet (possible to become a primary bdrm bath). Attractive Fully Tiled bath w/Bathtub, Glass Doors & new Pedestal Sink. 2 Additional Spacious Bedrooms complete the upper level. Lower level features 2 separate spaces for current Owners Adult Children. Entire House can be used as one massive home and opened up! Currently 2 Ground Floor Bedrooms. Each with their own updated Full Baths and HUGE Summer Kitchen Space (that can all be bedrooms w/ baths) or large Family Room. Separate entry for each. Private Laundry Room and Boiler Room. Hardwood Floors. 3-zone Gas Heat & Cooking. Central Air. 5 Ceiling Fans through-out! Oversized Rear Yard is fenced with a Large Patio Area for 1 or 2 outdoor seating areas. Entertainers Delight, perfect for summer BBQ's & get-together's! Deep Park-like backyard. Plenty of Room for Pool, Playset, Trampoline & more! Beautiful Mature Professional Landscape with Perennials. This Home is Occupied by only 1 Meticulous family for 35 years, since built. Love, Care & Happiness Live Here and Now you Can too!! Hurry this one will go fast! Very unique set up! Get in this summer, just in time to enjoy easy beach days, summer breezes & BBQ's in your private back yard, all before school starts! Centrally & Conveniently located moments to your hearts desires! 10 min (3.5 miles) to Deer Park LIRR. 4 min (1 mile) to South Shore Mall. 13 min (5 miles) to Islip Beach or 14 min (11 miles) to Robert Moses Beach. Moments to Shopping, Dining, Entertainment, Parkways! Are you still reading? You Found it! This is it! Schedule your appointments today, for anytime AFTER June 5th! Send Pre-Approvals NOW to schedule and be the FIRST to Present your Offers! The Next Move is Yours! Your Home Awaits!
1990 | 5 | 3 | 2,465 sqft.
​
$724,999 - Bay Shore, NY
1580 Brentwood Road Bay Shore, NY - Welcome to this charming recently renovated Hi Ranch on Long Island! this stunning, light-filled home blends style and functionality. Featuring 6 spacious bedrooms and 2 full baths, it offers endless possibilities for comfortable, generational living - perfect for large families or those seeking flexibility. With a thoughtfully designed separate outside entrance, it's ideal for a mother-daughter setup, offering privacy while keeping loved ones close. The bright, airy spaces create a warm atmosphere you'll love coming home to, while the new gas hot forced heat system ensures year-round comfort and efficiency. Step outside and envision your dream garden - an outdoor oasis for relaxation and entertainment. Conveniently located close to shops, parks, and schools, this home combines charm and practicality. Don't Wait - homes like this don't last! Schedule your private showing today and make this beautiful Long Island property yours!
1962 | 6 | 2 | 1,817 sqft.
​
$700,000 - Bay Shore, NY
912 Hampshire Road Bay Shore, NY - Amply sized ranch home in the heart of West Bay Shore! This well-cared-for home offers 1,436 sq ft of living space on an expansive .46-acre property. It features 7 rooms including 3 generously sized bedrooms, 2 full baths, and a 1 car garage. Highlights include gleaming, just refinished wood floors, central air conditioning, a full basement, and an in-ground sprinkler system. The kitchen and bathrooms are fully functional and very well maintained, offering a great opportunity to update at your own pace. Enjoy easy access to the Sagtikos Parkway for quick commutes, and you're just minutes from Captree boat basin and Ocean Beaches. Plus, the Babylon LIRR station-offering both express and local service to Manhattan and Brooklyn-is conveniently nearby. A solid value in a prime South Shore location! Do not miss the open houses!
1961 | 3 | 2 | 1,430 sqft.
​
$699,990 - Bay Shore, NY
18-1 Locust Drive Bay Shore, NY - Nestled on 1.23 Acres of Parklike Grounds Set Way Back off Street. Lovely Oversized Home With Open Floor Plan and 2,500sqft of Living Space Features Room for Everyone Including 5 Generous Size Bedrooms, 3 Full Baths, 2nd Floor Brand New Kitchen, Living Room with Vaulted Ceilings, Formal Dining Room, Primary with En Suite, 2 Dens, Attached Garage and More! Many Updates thruout Including Lighting, Whole House Freshly Painted, Decking, Refinished Floors, New Carpet and More!
1997 | 5 | 3 | 2,534 sqft.
​
$699,950 - Bay Shore, NY
53 Mystic Circle Bay Shore, NY - Welcome to this stunning and spacious end unit condo, designed for comfort and style. Featuring soaring cathedral ceilings and a cozy double-sided fireplace between the living and dining rooms, this home offers a warm and inviting atmosphere for both relaxing and entertaining. The large eat-in kitchen is complete with granite countertops and ample space for casual dining. for morning coffee Enjoy the privacy and convenience of a side-door entry, plus a two-car garage. Triple slider lead to spacious deck, with a peek of the tennis court, perfect for morning coffee or evening gatherings. This home also offers access to community amenities, including a swimming pool, tennis courts, and a clubhouse.
1993 | 3 | 2 | 1,890 sqft.
​
$699,000 - Bay Shore, NY
30 W Belmont Street Bay Shore, NY - Welcome to this stunning colonial in the heart of Bay Shore! This spacious and beautifully maintained home offers 5 generously sized bedrooms and 3 full bathrooms, providing ample space for comfortable living and extended guests. The layout includes a bright and airy living room, a formal dining area, and a large eat-in kitchen perfect for gatherings and everyday meals. Step outside and enjoy a big, beautiful backyard, ideal for entertaining, relaxing, or play. The long private driveway offers plenty of parking for multiple vehicles—great for hosting and convenience. Located near shops, restaurants, parks, and major transportation, this home offers both comfort and accessibility in a vibrant Bay Shore community.
1953 | 5 | 3 | 2,496 sqft.
​
$699,000 - Bay Shore, NY
444 Brook Avenue Bay Shore, NY - Featuring this beautiful Hi - Rach with 6brs and 2 full baths. Perfect for a big Family - convenient location in Bay Shore with Sewer system yet far from the water (YOU do not need flooding insurance). The house conveniently has natural gas and is attractively located at a close proximity of Malls, Restaurants, Highways, shopping centers, places of worship and more. - The beautiful beaches of Robert Moses are within 20-minute range. - Completely updated in 2023, this house has a lot of potential for the family who is looking to turn the key and be happy. This is the home that YOU have being waiting for.
2000 | 6 | 2 | 1,720 sqft.
​
$699,000 - Bay Shore, NY
444 Brook Avenue Bay Shore, NY - Featuring this beautiful Hi - Rach with 6brs and 2 full baths. Perfect for a big Family - convenient location in Bay Shore with Sewer system yet far from the water (YOU do not need flooding insurance). The house conveniently has natural gas and is attractively located at a close proximity of Malls, Restaurants, Highways, shopping centers, places of worship and more. - The beautiful beaches of Robert Moses are within 20-minute range. - Completely updated in 2023, this house has a lot of potential for the family who is looking to turn the key and be happy. This is the home that YOU have being waiting for.
2000 | 6 | 2 | 1,720 sqft.
​
$689,500 - Bay Shore, NY
38 18Th Avenue Bay Shore, NY - Welcome to your Dream Home! This stunning expanded ranch is a true Gem showcasing a perfect blend of modern and functionality, Completely Renovated a year ago from top to bottom sparing no details. As you step into the home you are welcomed by an inviting Formal Living and 2 bedrooms, leading to the generously sized Custom Kitchen featuring sleek Stainless Steel Appliances, Quartz Countertops, and plenty of cabinet space. Entertain guests in the spacious Formal Dining Room and Cozy Den. Upstairs , you have 3 oversized bedrooms and a full bath offering comfort and privacy. You also have a full garage and dedicated Laundry Room for added convenience. Outside the home offers an oversized parklike back yard with a brand new paver patio and fire pit, perfect for outdoor entertaining and family gatherings. The Home is centrally located near all major highways and Long Island Railroad. Don't miss the oppurtunity to make this oasis your Home!
1953 | 5 | 2 | 1,611 sqft.