Bay Shore New York homes for sale starting at Fifty Thousand Dollars

$5,000,000 - Bay Shore, NY

101 West Lane Bay Shore, NY - Step into a legacy of craftsmanship with the legendary Hoffritz Cutlery Estate, nestled in the prestigious Oconee Estate section of Bay Shore. Sprawling across over three private acres and boasting nearly 1,000 feet of prime waterfront, including nearly 700 feet along the Lawrence Canal. This remarkable property offers a rare blend of grandeur, history, and endless potential. At the heart of the estate lies a stately 7,000+ sq ft 1950s Contemporary, originally built to the exacting standards of the famed Hoffritz family. This 12-room home features 5 spacious bedrooms, 4 full bathrooms, and 2 half baths, blending timeless architectural elegance with the unique charm of a storied past. But the opportunity doesn’t stop there. For the visionary developer or investor, the property holds the potential to be subdivided into three stunning waterfront parcels - two canal-front sites and one spectacular bayfront site - perfect for crafting an enclave of new luxury estates or “McMansions” with water access and panoramic views (house sold as is). The crown jewel: a bayfront site offering unrivaled vistas of the Great South Bay, the barrier beaches, and the iconic Fire Island Lighthouse - a setting that promises coastal living at its most inspiring. Whether you’re seeking a one-of-a-kind personal estate, or a chance to develop three luxury homes in one of Long Island’s most coveted waterfront enclaves, this is your opportunity to secure a piece of history—and the future. Come see for yourself. Experience the dream.

$2,999,900 - Bay Shore, NY

115 S Saxon Avenue Bay Shore, NY - Waterfront! Relax In Privacy In This Secluded, Oversized 7000 Sq. Ft. Bay Front Ranch With Large 2 Car Garage. Gorgeous, Heated Igp And 250 Ft. Of Bulkhead With Electric Boat Lift & Large Cut In For Boat. Islip Schools. Iconic Views Of Great South Bay In A Classic, Resort Like Setting., Additional information: Appearance:Mint,Separate Hotwater Heater:2

$2,299,000 - Bay Shore, NY

913 Gardiner Drive Bay Shore, NY - Welcome To This Stunning 6 Bedroom, 3 Full Bath, 2 Half Bath Colonial With Over 3800 Sq. Ft. of Living Space. Lg Living Room, Den w/Fireplace, Formal Dining Room, EIK w/Center Island, Granite and Stainless Appliances, Primary Suite w/Full Bath and WIC. 2-Car Attached Garage Lovely Tree-Lined Property, Paver Patio, Stone Firepit & In-Ground Pool for Relaxing and Entertaining!, Additional information: Appearance: Diamond Complete interior renovation in 2022, complete exterior renovation in 2024!

$1,225,000 - Bay Shore, NY

17 Mowbray Avenue Bay Shore, NY - Exceptional Luxury Home Near Southshore Hospital and the Beach Introducing an incredible opportunity to own a stunning home in a prime location! With millions of dollars being invested in Southshore Hospital, now is the perfect time to secure this beautiful property. Located just a minute’s walk from the hospital and a 15-minute stroll to the beach and ferry, this home offers unmatched convenience and luxury. Key Features: Gourmet Kitchen: Recently remodeled with high-end appliances, double waterfall islands, and exquisite finishes. Master King Suite: Includes a sauna, jacuzzi, spa, heated toilet, and more. Enjoy breathtaking sunrises and sunsets from the comfort of your bedroom. Luxurious Bathrooms: Featuring a huge master bath with a shower, soaking tub, and tremendous closet space. Elegant Living Spaces: A grand sitting area with a fireplace, perfect for cozy gatherings. Prime Location: Close proximity to Fire Island, Southshore Hospital, and Main Street Downtown. Additional Information: ParkingFeatures:2 Car Attached,

$1,200,000 - Bay Shore, NY

7 S Bay Avenue Bay Shore, NY - This brand-new, beautifully designed home offers a modern living experience with breathtaking water views at every turn. From the moment you step through the front door, you're greeted by open, airy spaces filled with natural light and an inviting atmosphere. The contemporary architecture and sleek, clean lines give the home a timeless yet fresh appeal. The heart of the home is the spacious living area, which seamlessly transitions into the state-of-the-art kitchen featuring high-end finishes, premium appliances, and a large island perfect for both cooking and entertaining. Expansive windows throughout the home frame the stunning water views, making it feel like the outdoors is an extension of your living space. Step out onto the private deck or balcony, where you can enjoy the beauty of the water and relax in your own tranquil haven. The master suite offers a luxurious retreat, with its own private view of the water and a spa-like en-suite bathroom designed with modern finishes, including a soaking tub with a view. Whether you’re relaxing in the open-concept living spaces or enjoying the outdoors, this new home offers an unparalleled combination of modern convenience and nature’s beauty. It’s the perfect place for those who appreciate both stylish living and the calming influence of being close to the water. Property is still under development pictures are staged - there is still time to select your choices such as paint and fixtures.

$999,999 - Bay Shore, NY

44 S Montgomery Avenue Bay Shore, NY - Gracious Waterfront Colonial South of Montauk! Step into timeless elegance at this stately 12-room Colonial nestled on a rare 75’ wide waterfront lot with bulkhead and bay access. Boasting over 5,400 sq. ft. of living space, this 5-bedroom, 4-bath residence combines classic charm with spacious modern living. Highlights include formal living and dining rooms, a sun-drenched family room, sunroom, and a grand primary suite with dual walk-in closets. The third floor offers two additional bedrooms, a sitting room, and bath—perfect for guests or extended family. Enjoy summer nights by the water, host gatherings around the fire pit or gas grill, and take in serene views from the lush 16,553 sq. ft. lot. Located just south of Montauk Highway, this home is close to South Shore University Hospital, shopping, and Bay Shore’s vibrant village amenities. A rare opportunity to own a historic gem with modern updates in one of Bay Shore’s most desirable waterfront enclaves. House also offers 2 car detached garage with full standing room attic.

$998,000 - Bay Shore, NY

57 Maple Av. Bay Shore, NY - Victorian Elegance Meets Bayshore Lifestyle at 57 Maple Avenue Set on a quiet, tree-lined, no-parking street just steps from Bay Shore’s vibrant Main Street, this timeless 1930s Victorian offers more than charm — it offers flexibility, luxury, and serious lifestyle potential. Surrounded by lush, fenced-in grounds, the home is a true retreat in the heart of one of Suffolk County’s most walkable and thriving waterfront towns. Inside, you'll find 4 spacious bedrooms, 3 bathrooms, original hardwood floors, intricate moldings, and a gracious layout with formal living and dining rooms, an inviting parlor with fireplace, and a sunny eat-in kitchen perfect for casual meals or hosting. But what truly sets this property apart is the massive two-story garage — well over 1,000 square feet — built for the visionary. The first level features double-height ceilings, ideal for installing a lift and working on vehicles, or easily accommodating 4 to 8 cars. Whether you’re a car enthusiast, collector, or small business owner, this space is a dream. Upstairs, the second floor is currently set up as a recreational space, perfect for entertaining, working from home, or even converting into a legal rental or guest unit (with proper permits). Add in the unbeatable location: just blocks from the ferry to Fire Island, the nightlife of Main Street, local breweries, waterfront dining, and the Bay Shore Marina. The no-parking street means a rare level of tranquility in such a central location. Whether you're looking to live, work, play — or all three — this one-of-a-kind home delivers.

$934,900 - Bay Shore, NY

906 Thompson Drive Bay Shore, NY - Colonial Style Home. This Home Features 5 Bedrooms, 3.5 Baths, Formal Dining Room, Eat In Kitchen & Den W/ Fireplace. Centrally Located To All. Don't Miss This Opportunity!

$925,000 - Bay Shore, NY

6 West Shore Road Bay Shore, NY - Sublime & Magnificent, A Truly Remarkable One Of A Kind Location Steps From Walker Park & Beach, Just Four Houses From The Bay Shore Yacht Club, One Block From The Brightwaters Grand Concourse/Canal, Just A Short Drive To The Robert Moses Causeway & 2.2 Miles To The Fire Island Ferry...This Stunning Home & Location Offers The Epitome Of Resort Style Living & Is Perfect For A Year Round Residence Or Wonderful Second Home/Summer Getaway! Beautiful Curb Appeal - Meticulous Landscape, Belgium Block Curbing, Lighted Stone Columns, Brick/Paver Walkways, 4+ Car Driveway, Brick/Paver Apron & Covered Front Paver Porch, And The Interior Of The Home Offers An Impeccably Upgraded & Detailed, Elegant Floorplan - Formal Entrance Foyer With An Andersen Fiberglass Door, Diagonal Ceramic Tile Floors, Custom Moldings & Recessed Lighting, Designer Half Bath/Powder Room With Glass Tiled Walls, Bombe Vanity & Accent Oval Andersen Window, Step Down Inviting Formal Living Room With Large Bay Window (Southern Exposure), Stunning Crown, Door & Window Moldings, Custom Box Paneled/Wainscoted Walls & Ample Room For Furniture, Elegant Formal Dining Room Also With Stunning Custom Crown Moldings, Bay Window, Chandelier, Diagonal Ceramic Tile Floors & Opens Into The Magnificent Custom Chef's Kitchen With Expansive Walls Of Custom Cabinetry, All Custom Crown Moldings, Trims, Details & Stunning Custom Range Hood, Granite Countertops With A Double Undermount Sink & An Excess Of Counter/Serving Space, Stone Tiled Backsplash, Built In Large 4- 6 Person Barstool/Kitchen Table Area, 4 Pane Andersen Window Overlooking The Backyard, Stainless Steel Appliances - Built In Double Wall Oven (Convection & Bake), French Door Refrigerator With Bottom Freezer, Water & Ice Maker, Thermador Cooktop, Sharp Microwave Drawer, Garbage Disposal, Instant Hot Water, Custom Baking Pan Racks, Spice Drawers & An Abundance Of Pantries/Storage Spaces. Off Of The Kitchen Is The Step Down Den/Family Room Offering A Showpiece Natural Gas Fireplace With Marble Walls/Surround, Custom Mantel, Moldings & Columns, 4 Pane Andersen Window Overlooking The In Ground Pool, 24" x 24" Granite Tiled Floors & Sliding Doors To The Backyard, A Separate Media Room/Rec Room (Or Large Home Office Or Home Gym) With All Custom Built In Cabinetry (Wall Unit, Full Wall Desk & Storage Cabinetry) & Ample Room For Furniture/Seating, And A Large Utility Room With A Three Zone Gas Heating System & Gas Hot Water Heater (Plus A 200 Amp Electric Panel & Separate Sub Panel). The Second Level Of The Home Offers An Expansive, Elegant Primary Bedroom Suite With Large Beautiful Windows For Natural Light, Stunning Custom Moldings & Crown Moldings, Ample Room For A Large Bedroom Set/Furniture & Lots Of Closet Space/Storage, And The Beautifully Renovated Primary Bathroom Offers A Stunning Corner Shower With All Beautiful Mosaic Tilework, Custom Moldings, Tile Floors, Pedestal Sink & Upgraded Fixtures, The First Guest Bedroom Is Colossal With Room For A Separate Seating Area (Or Home Office), Beautiful Angled Ceilings & Doghouse Window, The Second Guest Bedroom Is Primary Bedroom Sized With Multiple Windows For Light, Ample Room For Furniture & Ample Closet Storage, The Third Guest Bedroom Is Well Sized With Two Corner Windows For Natural Light, Ample Room For Furniture & A Good Sized Closet, And The Beautifully Renovated Guest Bathroom Offers A Wonderful Stone Topped Vanity, Full Bathtub With All Beautiful Ceramic Tilework, Plank Ceramic Tile Floors & Upgraded Fixtures. The Entertainer's Backyard Is A Bountiful Oasis - Green Giant Privacy Trees, Montauk Daisies, Azalea, Hydrangea, Japanese Maple Trees, Rose Bushes, Butterfly Bushes, Hostas, Forsythia, Brick/Paver Patios, Planter Boxes, Walls & Entertaining Areas, Irrigation System, PVC Fencing & A Spectacular Kidney Shaped Saltwater Heated In Ground Pool, Paver Patio & Pool Surround. An Impressive Home & Location For The Discerning Buyer, And Not To Be Missed!

$899,000 - Bay Shore, NY

82 Harbour Lane Bay Shore, NY - Enjoy a coveted lifestyle beyond the privet hedge at the gated HOA at the Admiralty situated on 100 acres of the truly special former Thorne Estate on the Great South Bay. Thoughtfully designed, gracious, and inviting best describe this impeccable 3 bedroom, 2.5 bath 2700 square foot Atlantis model. The flow of rooms filled with abundant natural light and custom millwork combine to deliver space that is both elegant and highly liveable. A well appointed kitchen with a breakfast nook is centered between the formal dining room and the living room with a fireplace and a wall of sliding glass doors opening onto the brick patio. The cozy den offers a quiet retreat with its custom built entertainment center. An amply outfitted private office is perfect for working from home. The primary bedroom is generously proportioned complete with sitting alcove, dual walk-in closets, en suite bathroom, and terrace. Two additional queen sized bedrooms with adjacent hall bathroom complete the second level. HOA amenities include arboretum quality grounds, clubhouse, gym, protected marina with kayak/SUP launch, pool, tennis, pickleball, bocce ball court, and adjacent nature conservancy/bird sanctuary. Vibrant downtown Bay Shore, Fire Island Ferries, two major hospitals, and more are just minutes away. Come visit and discover your sense of place!

Bay Shore, New York listings for sale

End of list

There were no properties mapped for this search