Cape May, New Jersey listings for sale

$7,995,000 - Cape May, NJ

1736 New York Cape May, NJ - Welcome to 1736 New York Avenue, a truly rare opportunity to own a one-of-a-kind beachfront home in one of Cape May’s most exclusive neighborhoods. This 5 bedroom, 4 bathroom, 3-story home offers ultimate privacy, seclusion, and coastal retreat, complete with your own private path to the beach. Step into the foyer and head down to the expansive middle level, where you'll find a spacious family room, three well-appointed bedrooms, and two full baths. A utility room offers generous storage space, along with a laundry/second utility room. The large deck off the family room creates an ideal space for relaxing or entertaining, and a side entrance adds convenience for guests. The top floor is the heart of the home, featuring a spectacular great room with breathtaking panoramic ocean views, a dining area, a bright, open kitchen, and a wet bar sink. This level also offers a guest bedroom with a nearby full bath and a primary suite with an ensuite bath and access to the wraparound porch and another small private deck. Step out onto the expansive oceanfront deck, which wraps around to enhance the stunning coastal experience. An additional highlight includes the ground level which offers an oversized garage for added convenience. Whether you're seeking a peaceful year-round residence or a seaside escape, 1736 New York Avenue offers it all. Don't miss your chance to live where the ocean is your backyard!

$6,175,000 - Cape May, NJ

821 Beach Cape May, NJ - What an Amazing Home and LOCATION!!! This Spectacular 8 Bedroom 5 1/2 Bathroom Oceanfront Victorian is located along Cape May’s “Mansion Row” in the Victorian Historic District along the Beach with unbelievable views of the Beach and Ocean and walking distance to the Downtown Dining, Shopping and Entertainment District. Enter the Home through the Front Sunroom into the Spacious Family Room with Fireplace, perfect for Family gatherings and enjoying the views. The First Floor is an open layout into the Newly Upgraded oversized Kitchen, Living Room, Bathroom, and a Laundry Room with 2 washers and 2 dryers. The oversized Family Room Stairway brings you to the Second Floor which has 6 Bedrooms and 4 newly Upgraded Bathrooms. The Front 2 Bedrooms have a Deck to enjoy the view of the Beach and Ocean. The Third floor runs from front to back has been transformed into bedrooms with a full Bathroom and Spectacular View of the Ocean. Relax on the front porch, stare at the ocean, and walk back into time. There is room in the private rear yard for a pool which will need to be permitted. This Victorian Beauty comes FULLY FURNISHED! Make an appointment to see this one in a million! Come and see this Gem!

$6,175,000 - Cape May, NJ

821 Beach Dr Cape May, NJ - What an Amazing LOCATION!!! This Spectacular Oceanfront Victorian is located along Cape May's ""Mansion Row""Â? in the Victorian Historic District along the Beach with unbelievable views of the Beach and Ocean and walking distance to the Downtown Dining and Entertainment District. Enter the Home through the Front Sun Room into the Spacious Family Room with Fireplace, perfect for Family gatherings and enjoying the views. The First Floor is an open layout into the Newly Upgraded oversized Kitchen. The First Floor also includes a Living Room, Bedroom and Bathroom, and a Laundry Room with 4 washers and dryers. The oversized Family Room Stairway brings you to the Second Floor which has 9 Bedrooms and 7 newly Upgraded Bathrooms. The Front 2 Bedrooms have a Deck to enjoy the view of the Beach and Ocean. The Attic which runs from front to back has been transformed into bedrooms with a Spectacular View of the Ocean. Relax on the front porch, stare at the ocean, and walk back into time. This Victorian Beauty comes FULLY FURNISHED! Make an appointment to see this one in a million! Come and see this Gem! This Home was originally a B&B and transformed into a Beautiful Family Home. It comes with it's own Web Site consisting of approximately 2000 contacts. Today this home rents for approximately $9,000 per week. Annual rental income information is available. Most of the interior of the Home has recently been upgraded. The Front Exterior, Front Entry Room, and new front porch is currently under construction and being upgraded. The Owner is willing to work with any potential Buyer regarding the choice of Finish Materials.

$6,175,000 - Cape May, NJ

821 Beach Avenue Cape May, NJ - What an Amazing Home and LOCATION!!! This Spectacular 8 Bedroom 5 1/2 Bathroom Oceanfront Victorian is located along Cape May's ""Mansion Row""Â? in the Victorian Historic District along the Beach with unbelievable views of the Beach and Ocean and walking distance to the Downtown Dining, Shopping and Entertainment District. Enter the Home through the Front Sunroom into the Spacious Family Room with Fireplace, perfect for Family gatherings and enjoying the views. The First Floor is an open layout into the Newly Upgraded oversized Kitchen, Living Room, Bathroom, and a Laundry Room with 2 washers and 2 dryers. The oversized Family Room Stairway brings you to the Second Floor which has 6 Bedrooms and 4 newly Upgraded Bathrooms. The Front 2 Bedrooms have a Deck to enjoy the view of the Beach and Ocean. The Third floor runs from front to back has been transformed into bedrooms with a full Bathroom and Spectacular View of the Ocean. Relax on the front porch, stare at the ocean, and walk back into time. There is room in the private rear yard for a pool which will need to be permitted. This Victorian Beauty comes FULLY FURNISHED! Make an appointment to see this one in a million! Come and see this Gem!

$4,425,000 - Cape May, NJ

24 Ocean Cape May, NJ - This magnificent home has served many purposes over the years: a private residence, beach retreat, bed and breakfast, and a highly successful large family vacation rental. Now, she awaits her next chapter! Perhaps, like previous owners, you’ll step inside and instantly feel it’s the “one.” The original builders seemed to have envisioned just such a future, designing her with the space and structure to support endless possibilities. With generous living areas, spacious bedrooms, each featuring ensuite or private bathrooms, The Breakers offers comfort and charm at every turn. Guests will enjoy breathtaking views of the beach and ocean sunsets from the sundecks or the expansive wraparound porch perfect for everything from sipping coffee to cocktails! And let’s not forget the rare off-street parking for up to 8 cars—an invaluable feature in Cape May. Currently an 8-bedroom, 9-bathroom home just half a block from the beach, The Breakers has been lovingly operated as a whole-house rental for over 13 years, with a current peak weekly rental rate of $15,000. A few of its newest upgrades include new leather sleeper sofas replacing the living room futons, Google Nest smart thermostats, smart locks on front/back doors and entire home upgraded with wifi mesh system with 3 hubs for strong signal throughout house. This home comes mostly furnished, offering a seamless transition for its new owner. Whether you envision continuing its legacy as a sought-after vacation rental, keeping it just for your ever-growing family or bringing your own vision to life…maintaining the Victorian charm with modern upgrades or embracing a beachy coastal theme—the possibilities are endless. Located just steps from the beach, the Washington Street Mall, shops, restaurants, and cafes, this stunning property is perfectly situated to enjoy all that Cape May has to offer. A true gem, meticulously maintained and full of potential, The Breakers is waiting for YOU. Whatever your dream, this iconic home is ready to make it a reality.

$3,490,000 - Cape May, NJ

2 Pharo Cape May, NJ - Welcome to 2 Pharo, a 4-story, single family property, iconic to Cape May's Marina District and the surrounding waterfront enclave known as Spicers Creek. This unique property offers the opportunity to enjoy water views from each floor, spanning North, South, East and West, from sunrise to sunset. Planning by Fenwick Architects with steel posts and beams, brick and cedar shake exterior, executed and customized by WKR Builders, this property is built to withstand the test of time. It is a residential machine with 4 stories, 4 bedrooms (with a lofted area for a potential 5th), 2 full bathrooms and 2 lavatories, multiple decks for your outdoor enjoyment, an attached garage, an elevator accessible to all 4 stories, remarkable interior design with an effortless, yet elevated, comfortable and refined style. Entering the front door there is a tumbled marble foyer that follows into the hallway to a half bathroom or to the rear of the property which is the entertainment room, home to the customized bar and lounge area with Anderson doors and windows that open to the brick patio for full views of the waterfront facing south. The garage is also attached on this 1st floor level with plenty of storage, a commercial grade ice machine and additional refrigerator/freezer. The 2nd floor is where you will find the breathtaking primary bedroom complete with separate walk-in closets, an ensuite bathroom with 2 stationary vanities, a massive walk-in shower and 9-foot ceilings that offer views facing South, East and West. There are 3 additional guest bedrooms on this floor, a full guest bathroom in the hallway and a separate laundry room. The 3rd level is absolutely magnificent with stunning waterfront views that are abundant facing North, South, East and West. The cathedral ceiling peaks over the living room with a gas fireplace and the adjacent dining area for a table to seat 10 guests, or more, comfortably. There are 4 sets of Andersen French doors that open entirely to the covered porch facing south, with an unforgettable sunset showcase for you to enjoy every day. The kitchen displays a modern aesthetic with clean lines and large windows on the east and west facade. There is a covered porch off of the kitchen facing north and west to Schellenger's Landing. The 4th floor is your lofted living room, additional living space that opens to the 4th floor deck with even more unforgettable views, overlooking the surrounding Cape May Marina District, from Schellenger's Landing to the Harbor. Spicers Creek at Cape May Marina is home to The Paddle Club, for an additional fee, this private club offers two saltwater pools, one of which is heated, plenty of outdoor entertaining space with a bar and grille area. For the boater, a slip accompanying a vessel up to 70 feet is available for additional fees as well. There is a HOA fee of $225/QTR for common area maintenance. 2 Pharo is unparalleled in construction, with thoughtful design, discerning engineering and energy efficient mechanics. This is a most unique property with an exclusive sunset view that is unrivaled to Cape May. 2 Pharo is being conveyed fully furnished, less personal items, and is shown by appointment only.

$3,290,000 - Cape May, NJ

1125 Maryland Cape May, NJ - This new construction designer home by FX Construction offers an array of luxurious features and thoughtful design elements. Expected completion date July. The property features five bedrooms and 4.5 baths, with designer finishes and substantial materials. The first floor includes an open foyer, a suite, and two large bedrooms with a hall bath, one contains a built-in twin up/king down bunk bed. The spacious family room overlooks the rear yard, with an optional pool package available. An additional powder room and a large laundry/changing area complete the first floor. The second floor, accessible by elevator or stairs, features a large vaulted great room with shiplap ceilings, fireplace, and multi-paneled doors leading to screened and open porches. The primary suite has a private balcony, vaulted shiplap ceilings, a walk-in closet, and a bath with a double sink, a walk-in shower, and a free-standing tub. The home's exterior boasts smart venting, an eco-friendly EP Henry paver driveway, walkway, and patio, and an optional pool package for $75,000. Additionally, you can opt for a gas-lined fire pit and extended patio for $10,000, creating the perfect outdoor space for relaxation and entertainment. Please request the full packet for details. 5 5/8 Bamboo hardwood flooring throughout, designer classic tiles selected. 6” trim and cottage door crowns, three electric windows, EP Henry paver drive and patio. Bamboo ceiling and bamboo flooring are on the front porch. CertainTeed Landmark Pro Roof with 130 mph wind resistance and a 50-year limited warranty, Allura cement board siding, and stainless-steel cable railings. Built with pride and confidence. Can be completed by mid-July. Selections have been made, but the Buyer might make a few changes if time allows. Shown by appointment only. Construction site – kindly, no children, pets, and please closed-toed shoes. Thank you!

$2,999,000 - Cape May, NJ

225-227 Windsor Cape May, NJ - Slip off your sandals and stroll home from the surf, your Cape May hideaway awaits on storybook Windsor Avenue, a tree-lined lane moments from the beach, Washington Street Mall, and every eatery, bar, and boutique in town. Behind handcrafted double doors, this six-bedroom, 3.5-bath retreat marries the grace of Victorian Cape May with an easy, contemporary flow- proof that timeless charm and modern comfort can coexist beautifully. The main residence features 5 bedrooms and 2.5 baths, with a strong rental history, giving you the option to rent the entire front of the house for proven income potential. A private rear 1-bed/1-bath apartment—with its own entrance, kitchenette, patio, and outdoor shower—has always been owner-occupied but offers exceptional flexibility as an owner’s suite or future rental opportunity. Host extended family, create a private retreat, or tailor the spaces to your lifestyle. A deep front porch begs for iced tea and people-watching, while a breezy screened porch lounge waits for morning coffee or curling up with a great book. Two paver patios nestle into lush, low-maintenance gardens, and the grounds deliver dual outdoor showers, a bike rack, a storage shed, and coveted off-street parking for four (stacked), everything you need for seamless shore living. Rebuilt from the ground up in 1980, the home features coastal-tough cement-board siding, natural-gas heat, and central air. Yet inside you’ll find soaring ceilings, classic millwork, and thoughtful details that echo Cape May’s historic pedigree—proof that a newer build can still honor the neighborhood’s elegant past. Whether you envision a generational beach compound or a turn-key investment with serious earning power, this Windsor Avenue classic delivers location, versatility, and that signature Cape May Victorian charm. Note: Home is tenant-occupied until August 16. Showings available Saturdays 11:00 AM–1:30 PM; tenants return at 2:00 PM. Please call Listing Agents to schedule a Saturday Showing.

$2,995,000 - Cape May, NJ

1208 New Jersey Cape May, NJ - Where luxury meets location—this home checks all the boxes. Designed to capture the charm and timeless appeal of historic Cape May, this stunning 6-bedroom, 3.5-bath coastal retreat offers all the modern comforts in one of the most coveted locations in town. With classic cedar shake-style siding, rich engineered wood floors throughout, and sun-filled interiors, this home blends Old Cape May elegance with resort-style living. Ideally located just steps from the beach on the highly desirable beach block, you’re perfectly positioned to enjoy everything Cape May has to offer. Take a short stroll to the sand, bike into town for coffee and shopping, or enjoy family-friendly movies under the stars behind Convention Hall. Cape May is one of America’s oldest seaside resort towns, and this home allows you to experience it at its best. Outdoors, a private fenced backyard features a beautifully designed patio area and in-ground pool with water feature—ideal for summer gatherings, afternoon cocktails, or simply unwinding in your own sanctuary. Multiple levels of open-air porches offer ocean breezes and a peek of the Atlantic from the second-floor deck off the master suite. Inside, the spacious yet cozy layout was designed for both entertaining and relaxation. The first floor features an open-concept floor plan with seamless flow from the living room to the dining area and kitchen. A double-sided gas fireplace adds warmth and charm, perfect for relaxing after a day at the beach. The kitchen is a chef’s dream—elegant and functional, with plenty of space for multiple cooks to prepare meals and treats, whether it’s Sunday dinner or summer snacks whipped up by “NoNa.” The second-floor master suite spans the entire rear of the home and includes a private deck with ocean view, a luxurious en suite bathroom, and plenty of space to retreat in peace. Two oversized guest bedrooms on the same floor share a spacious hall bath, ideal for family or guests. The third floor includes three additional generous-sized bedrooms, providing flexibility for sleeping arrangements, home office space, or creative use. Additional highlights include: • Private outdoor shower with hot & cold water • New awnings for shade and curb appeal • Off-street parking for added convenience • Long-standing, strong rental history • Turnkey opportunity as a second home, vacation rental, combination of, or full-time residence Whether you’re seeking an investment with proven returns or your dream home by the sea, this property offers exceptional value in one of Cape May’s most exclusive neighborhoods. The lifestyle you’ve dreamed of is here—just a 1/2 block from the beach.

$2,800,000 - Cape May, NJ

828 Corgie Cape May, NJ - Welcome to 828 Corgie Street—A Timeless Victorian Twin in the Heart of Cape May’s Historic District. 828 Corgie St unit is a beautifully maintained 3-bedroom, 2 and 1/2 -bath residence that offers the perfect blend of classic charm and modern comfort. The spacious first floor features an open-concept great room, dining area, and kitchen with sliding doors leading to a generous rear deck—ideal for outdoor dining and entertaining. 828 1/2 Corgie St unit is a spacious 4-bedroom, 2 and 1/2 -bathroom residence offering a spacious layout ideal for year-round living or investment. The main level features 1st floor master, half bathroom and kitchen with sliders to a large deck—perfect for outdoor entertaining. Situated on an oversized 9,600 sq ft lot extending to Page Street, the property offers the possibility to add a pool, garage, or garden oasis. Owned solar panels provide energy efficiency and cost savings. With a strong rental history and a prime walk-to-everything location near beaches, shops, and restaurants, this home presents an excellent opportunity for investors or year-round residents alike. A rare chance to own a piece of Cape May history— rent one and enjoy the other as your own Cape May retreat.

Cape May, New Jersey listings for sale

End of list

There were no properties mapped for this search