Suttons Bay, Michigan listings for sale

​
$574,900 - Suttons Bay, MI
1830 S West Bay Shore Drive Suttons Bay, MI - Your Up North 0pportunity awaits! Acquire this ranch style home located between Traverse City & Suttons Bay in coveted Leelanau county. The house is tucked away from the road with a Cedar row that creates privacy and it features fresh paint, new flooring, new LED lighting new bathroom countertops and new vanities. It is light and bright with an open floor plan making it perfect for entertaining. The family room on the lower level is ready for your big screen or projection TV and cozy seating. There is a 4th conforming bedroom on the lower level awaitng new owners' finishing touches. There is an oversized 2 car garage with double doors (automatic openers). Seller will consider LC terms with well qualified buyer and substantial down payment. The grounds are like a private oasis. Step out the backdoor and enjoy the secluded partially wooded lot and the serenity of the forest out your backdoor. Ask me about seller concession options!
1986 | 4 | 3 | 2,096 sqft.
​
$499,900 - Suttons Bay, MI
8822 Bahle Road Suttons Bay, MI - Welcome to this well-maintained, original owner home offering breathtaking bay views and nestled among the trees on 1.8 acres just outside of beautiful Suttons Bay Village. Thoughtfully designed, this 3-bedroom, 2-bath ranch-style home features spacious rooms and an abundance of windows providing lovely views and natural lighting throughout. The main level includes a primary bedroom with a full en-suite bath, along with two additional bedrooms and a second full bath. Enjoy cozy evenings in the generous living room, highlighted by a charming fieldstone fireplace. The adjoining dining area includes a sliding door that opens to a wraparound deck—perfect for enjoying the stunning views of the bay and surrounding towering hardwoods. A large main-floor laundry room offers ample storage space for added convenience. The walkout lower level presents a blank canvas with two finished bedrooms ready for flooring, an area for a family room, additional storage, and direct access to the attached 2-car garage, this space easily transforms the home into a 5-bedroom residence. All of this just minutes from the charming village of Suttons Bay—don’t miss your opportunity to own a slice of Up North paradise.
1973 | 3 | 2 | 2,545 sqft.
​
$485,000 - Suttons Bay, MI
224 Saint Marys Street Suttons Bay, MI - Welcome to 224 Saint Marys Ave, a picturesque haven located in the heart of Suttons Bay, MI. This charming property seamlessly blends comfort, convenience, and stunning natural beauty, making it ideal for those seeking a serene lakeside lifestyle. Just a short stroll away, you'll find a variety of restaurants, bars, the Bay Theater, and public access to Suttons Bay beach, perfect for water enthusiasts. Directly across the street, there's a public park with a tennis, pickleball and basketball court, and directly located on the TART trail. Whether you're looking for a year-round residence or a seasonal getaway, this home offers an unparalleled lifestyle in one of Michigan's most desirable locations. Renovations began in 2017, resulting in extensive upgrades throughout the entire home. The kitchen now features quartz countertops and a modern backsplash, while wood flooring and new drywall have been installed throughout. Blown-in insulation ensures energy efficiency, and the bathroom boasts a brand-new shower area, sink, and lighting. Additional updates include a high-efficiency furnace, Anderson windows, and a three-season pavilion room with electricity off the new deck, offering views of Suttons Bay beach. Don't miss this rare opportunity to own a piece of paradise in Suttons Bay!
1910 | 2 | 2 | 1,104 sqft.
​
$475,000 - Suttons Bay, MI
11255 E Fort Road Suttons Bay, MI - Welcome to easy living in Suttons Bay! This beautifully updated two-story condo offers the perfect blend of modern comfort and Up North charm—just a short stroll from the marina, shopping, dining, and the scenic TART Trail. Step inside to find brand-new carpeting throughout, freshly painted kitchen cabinets, granite countertops, and two fully remodeled bathrooms—each outfitted with stylish walk-in showers. The primary bath features heated floors for that extra touch of luxury during Michigan winters. With three bright bedrooms, flexible bonus rooms ideal for a home office or gym, and ample storage, this 1,295 sq ft layout is both functional and inviting. You'll love the natural light pouring into the open-concept living room and kitchen—perfect for cozy evenings or casual entertaining. Sip your morning coffee or evening glass of wine from the private balcony, soaking in Suttons Bay’s peaceful village vibe. Practical updates include a new roof (2024), blown-in attic insulation for improved energy efficiency, and a water softener for everyday comfort. Association fee ($300/month) covers exterior building maintenance, lawn care, snow removal, garbage, shared septic & well. This is an end unit in the H building which offers a quiet location within the 44 acre complex Whether you're looking for a year-round residence, a seasonal escape, or a low-maintenance investment in one of Northern Michigan’s most desirable locations, this move-in-ready condo is a rare find. Shared amenities include an in-ground swimming pool, trails, tennis court, and a shared well & septic. Low maintenance living in a very convenient location just 10-15 minutes from Downtown Traverse City!
1988 | 3 | 2 | 1,244 sqft.
​
$425,000 - Suttons Bay, MI
1197 S West Bay Shore Drive Suttons Bay, MI - Location, location! Just one mile south of the vibrant Village of Suttons Bay, this 5-bedroom, 1-bath home offers an incredible opportunity to create your dream retreat in one of Leelanau County’s most sought-after areas. Nestled on scenic South West Bay Shore Drive, this one-and-a-half-story residence features wood flooring throughout the main level, a cozy galley kitchen, and a convenient laundry/mudroom that connects to a two-car attached garage. Upstairs, you'll find two generously sized bedrooms ready for your personal touch. With solid bones and loads of character, this home is brimming with potential—perfect for buyers with vision or investors looking for their next project. Bring your creativity and make this diamond in the rough shine!
1954 | 5 | 1 | 1,703 sqft.