Suttons Bay, Michigan listings for sale

​
$4,600,000 - Suttons Bay, MI
91 S Nanagosa Trail Suttons Bay, MI - Dream Home in Dream Location! Quiet Nanagosa Trail lends itself to biking along the shoreline to Suttons Bay in a matter of minutes. This gorgeous estate is set on a deep and extra wide double lot took years for owners to find. With 200' on sparkling West Bay, it offers luxury and privacy at the finest. Thoughtfully designed with exceptional details, the main house features an outside shower, two fireplaces, 5 bedroom, beautiful office & a glorious octagonal sunroom overlooking the water where you will want to spend all of your time. The gourmet kitchen includes details like a Wolf range, Sub-Zero fridge and Maple floors milled from the property. The wet bar has a live-edge countertop & fantastic fireplace. Throughout the home you will find elegant finishes like crystal knobs, heated bathroom floors, a clawfoot tub, and intricate tile work which elevates the space, while an elevator adds convenience. This thoughtfully designed home is nicely set up as a primary residence that has room to accommodate a large family and/or all the kids and grandkids. *The guest house, situated above a 6-car garage, boasts a full kitchen, its' own private deck overlooking the bay. It has a full kitchen, 2 bedrooms and pretty bathroom. *Outdoor highlights include expansive decks and patios, multiple gardens, sheds, copper gutters, a metal sunroom roof, and a long, private driveway. Combining luxury, comfort, and practicality, this exceptional waterfront estate is truly a rare find.
2019 | 7 | 5 | 6,244 sqft.
​
$3,990,000 - Suttons Bay, MI
10343 E Hilltop Road Suttons Bay, MI - Build your legacy in Leelanau County with this once-in-a-lifetime opportunity. Ciccone Vineyard and Winery is a sprawling estate with a strong brand in an ideal location, and an incredibly picturesque property with unobstructed views of Grand Traverse Bay from many vantage points. This trophy opportunity is completely turn-key with a successful wine and event business, as well as a Winemaker's home or bed and breakfast accommodations. Ciccone's award-winning wines are made exclusively from estate-grown grapes - produced and bottled on-site. Ciccone has a superb staff, a huge and growing wine club following, and the historic barn and event spaces are well-booked throughout the year. Built in 1990, the two story Winemaker's home has gorgeous views in all directions - with 5 bedrooms, 4.5 bathrooms, a large open main-level floor plan, immaculate grounds, and lots of outdoor entertainment spaces, the home has multiple potential uses including bed and breakfast, event guest space, and more. The kitchen has many updates including newer cabinets and counters, and the living areas all point to the views of the bay or the adjacent sprawling vineyard. The home is freshly painted, and has adequate storage areas as well as an attached three car garage. The Winemaker's home is also on its own 2 acre lot, which could be beneficial for flexible uses - or, it's a lovely primary home and perfectly positioned to oversee the entire Ciccone operation. In addition to the existing operation and lovely home, there is expansion potential as well. Plans for an onsite café, new production building, expanded vineyard potential, and event pavilion are all in hand and can be shared with the next steward of the property. The property consists of multiple parcels, which could be a flexible benefit as well. Sip award-winning wine from the back patio or the historic barn, overlooking sprawling vineyards, and a bay of blue. This Leelanau experience is definitely one to see in order to appreciate!
1995 | 4 | 4 | 3,520 sqft.
​
$1,750,000 - Suttons Bay, MI
705 S Nanagosa Trail Suttons Bay, MI - This stunning 3-bedroom, 2.5-bathroom home offers 100 feet of pristine waterfront on the Bay, blending comfort, elegance, and a true connection to nature. Enjoy the ease of main level living with an open floor plan that flows seamlessly from room to room, perfect for entertaining or quiet evenings at home. Warm wood floors add character and charm throughout the spacious primary rooms, while large windows/doors fill the space with natural light and frame breathtaking water views. The open-concept kitchen, dining, and living areas create a welcoming and functional space for everyday living. Experience year-round comfort in the stunning 4-season sunroom with in-floor heat and designed to bring the outdoors in—no matter the weather. Floor-to-ceiling windows fill the space with natural light, offering panoramic views in every season, from vibrant fall foliage to peaceful winter snowfalls. Step outside to your private outdoor oasis—complete with an artisan-style pizza oven, ideal for al fresco dining and unforgettable gatherings. Whether you're relaxing on the deck, cooking under the stars, or simply soaking in the beauty of the Bay, this home delivers the ultimate bayside lifestyle. The family/entertainment room on main level has plumbing for ice maker and outlets on east wall were placed above counter height to add cabinets & countertops.
1973 | 3 | 2 | 3,086 sqft.
​
$1,400,000 - Suttons Bay, MI
1451 S Bay View Trail Suttons Bay, MI - A hilltop sanctuary in the much sought after Suttons Bay neighborhood of "Stony Point" awaits your arrival! This stunning contemporary raised ranch home enjoys tree top unobstructed views of Lake Michigan below. Your 182 ft. of shared Lake Michigan beach frontage is nearby. Open floor plan-Main Level Living. Capture the first glimpses of the glorious sun rising in the East! This magnificent 3 bedroom 3 bath (one with soaker tub) home is located near the end on a private wooded cul de sac. Huge (new) windows display a panoramic view. Custom California closets. Two gas fireplaces. Quiet, Quiet, Quiet. Surrounded by lush woods. Watch a multitude of wild life from all windows. Enjoy hostessing your garden parties in the beautifully landscaped wrought iron fenced in yard. Spacious multiple level decks, walk out lower level, oversize extra deep epoxy coated floor in the two car garage.
1974 | 3 | 3 | 2,705 sqft.
​
$1,300,000 - Suttons Bay, MI
1551 N Macksey Road Suttons Bay, MI - 47 rolling Leelanau County acres is the setting of this one level, updated home near Suttons Bay. Beautiful acreage is a mix of hardwoods, planted pines and open ground. You will never tire of wandering your private park! Horses allowed by zoning. Barbeques or solitary afternoons are afforded by the private patio! Private primary bath w/tile shower. Main floor laundry, fireplace, original wood floors and large dining area. Full basement with finished areas and loads of storage! 30x60 heated pole building: concrete floor, 3 overhead doors, 1 sliding door and plumbing. Move in ready! Owner will consider selling west 20 acres separately. Floor Plan in camara roll.
1967 | 2 | 1 | 1,800 sqft.
​
$1,130,000 - Suttons Bay, MI
670 W Broadway Suttons Bay, MI - Imagine a home where tranquility meets convenience—where towering trees provide a natural sanctuary, yet downtown Suttons Bay is just moments away. This beautifully crafted residence offers a rare blend of privacy, elegance, and access to the best of Leelanau living. Thoughtful design and natural light abound with fresh paint throughout & all new engineered hardwood floors. A cozy fireplace serves as the heart of the open living space, while custom built-ins add charm and functionality. The beautifully remodeled kitchen is stylish and efficient. Shaker-style cabinetry, quartz countertops, and a deep farmhouse sink set the stage for effortless meal prep, and new stainless steel appliances, a spacious pantry, and coffee bar enhance everyday convenience. A built-in wine fridge keeps your best vintages at the perfect temperature, ensuring you're always ready to entertain. Whether gathered around the large kitchen island or enjoying the formal and informal dining spaces, this home is designed for connection. Updates continue throughout, including refreshed bathrooms with new vanities and mirrors, elevating style and function. Blending indoor and outdoor living, the home extends onto a spacious deck overlooking the backyard—the ideal place for morning coffee, evening entertaining, or quiet relaxation. Mature trees offer privacy to enjoy the backyard fire pit under the star filled Northern Michigan sky. The lower level features a walkout and egress windows, offering possibilities for additional living space—family room, game room, workout area, and more. But this home isn’t just about what’s inside—it’s about the lifestyle. Downtown Suttons Bay is just a half-mile away, to enjoy shopping, dining, or a movie at Bay Theater. Outdoor adventures abound at nearby parks and beaches along the bay. Stites Natural Area is just across the road—70 acres of spectacular ridge-line views and stunning fall colors. The best of Leelanau living awaits, come explore the possibilities!
1988 | 4 | 3 | 2,614 sqft.
​
$975,000 - Suttons Bay, MI
10400 E Youker Drive Suttons Bay, MI - One-of-a-kind, custom-built three-story home sitting on 20 private, wooded acres offering Leelanau charm and modern comfort. The main floor welcomes you with a warm foyer with custom live edge wood finishes to an open living place with natural light flooding the space from large windows. A gorgeous sunroom and spacious back deck offers serene views and a great space for relaxing or entertaining. The open living area features cathedral ceilings, skylights, and exposed wood beams, adding to the home’s inviting lodge-style atmosphere. At the heart of the living room is a stunning imported fireplace from Slovakia, Norway—an artisan centerpiece that adds both warmth and character. Upstairs, you’ll find a quiet study or den, perfect for working from home, and a charming loft area that overlooks the great room below. Above the attached garage is an unfinished room with great potential. Though currently unheated, it can be transformed into a gym, guest suite, or creative studio. The property also includes a large additional pole building for storage, equipment, or hobbies. Throughout the home, you’ll find beautiful wood details and craftsmanship that reflect the essence of a Up North lodge retreat. With Starlink internet already installed, you can enjoy high-speed connectivity in a peaceful, natural setting. Inspired by the feel of Lost Woods Lodge, this home is full of personality, warmth, and opportunity. Whether you're seeking a full-time residence, vacation getaway or income-producing short-term rental, this property is a rare find.
1988 | 3 | 3 | 3,093 sqft.
​
$899,000 - Suttons Bay, MI
2500 N Mork Road Suttons Bay, MI - Dating back to the 1890s, this home still whispers of its past while embracing the comforts of today. You’ll find timeless elements throughout such as original hardwood floors, intricate woodwork, built-in cabinetry, and vintage wallpaper that adds a whimsical, nostalgic charm. And while history is honored here, modern updates such as a geothermal heating and cooling system ensure everyday comfort. Just off the home, a fenced backyard offers a safe, sunny space for four-legged companions. Steps away, the barn stands tall—complete with silo and corncrib—the image is nothing short of magical. As the sunlight filters through the slatted walls, the space glows with quiet reverence. The main level features a solid barn floor and soaring ceilings, while the lower level reveals fieldstone walls, massive wood beams, and original feed mangers. If you’re still enough, you might hear the soft cooing of pigeons nesting in the old silo. Swing open the oversized doors and you’ll find yourself gazing at a green field, ready to be a pasture, gathering space, or something entirely its own. Beyond the barn, this property once thrived as a bustling cherry orchard. The property still features the old cherry tank wash pad and two versatile accessory buildings—perfect for hobbies, tools, a workshop or creativity. And the old chicken coop? It is patiently waiting to welcome its new feathered flock. A handful of old sweet and tart cherry trees, along with a lone Bartlett pear tree, still yield a tasty harvest each year. Established iris beds and garden areas yearn to add color to the grassy landscape. Whether you're dreaming of a self-sustaining lifestyle, creating art in a space that inspires you, hosting unforgettable gatherings under the stars, or simply longing for the peace of Leelanau County living—this property offers the soul and space to bring those dreams to life. This is not just a home—it's a place for new beginnings. A place to be inspired. A place to write your next chapter.
1890 | 4 | 2 | 2,758 sqft.
​
$740,000 - Suttons Bay, MI
400 W Broadway Suttons Bay, MI - Idyllic setting in Beautiful Suttons Bay! Energy efficient passive solar home, surrounded by beautiful hardwoods and within walking distance of the village and beach! This Three-bedroom, two-bath home abuts 11 acres for a very peaceful setting. Enjoy relaxing in the expansive sunroom on two levels; the floor plan is open on the main level, allowing all rooms to see outside. The kitchen is beautifully appointed, with quartz counters, stainless appliances, and an abundance of cabinets for storage. The upper bedrooms have a huge hidden closet that connects at either end for even more storage. With a prime location just minutes from the beach this is a great place to call home.
1982 | 3 | 2 | 1,781 sqft.
​
$699,000 - Suttons Bay, MI
215 N Saint Marys Street Suttons Bay, MI - Built in 1902 and thoughtfully maintained, this charming 4-bedroom, 2.5-bath cedar shake home is ideally situated in the heart of downtown Suttons Bay. Just one block from local shops, restaurants, and bars—and only two blocks from Suttons Bay Beach—this property showcases an unbeatable location that perfectly blends historic character with walkable village living. Set along the renowned Leelanau Wine Trail, the home offers convenient access to some of Northern Michigan’s most celebrated wineries. Step inside to discover light-filled living spaces spread across three levels. Rich wood floors add warmth and character throughout, while the flexible lower level serves as a recreation or bonus area—currently set up with a game room and a cozy space to gather or unwind. Outdoors, you’ll find a spacious backyard and garden area complete with a fire pit, gas grill, and plenty of room for entertaining guests. The big front porch invites you to sit back and enjoy the picturesque charm of downtown Suttons Bay, further enhancing the home's curb appeal. Additional highlights include proximity to public tennis courts, a neighborhood park, and a seasonal ice rink—all just one block away. This is a rare opportunity to own a piece of Suttons Bay history in one of the most desirable locations in Leelanau County.
1902 | 4 | 4 | 2,773 sqft.