Columbia City Indiana homes for sale starting at Fifty Thousand Dollars

$499,900 - Columbia City, IN

3139 E Colony Avenue Columbia City, IN - Stunning lakefront retreat with breathtaking views of the nature preserve on the peaceful west side of Round Lake! Enjoy the serenity from the expansive waterfront deck or through the large trapezoid windows that flood the great room with natural light. This beautifully maintained home underwent a major renovation just three years ago, featuring a new dimensional shingled roof, Andersen windows, a tankless water heater, and a show-stopping kitchen with custom Miller cabinets, soapstone countertops, subway tile backsplash, and all new appliances. The interior boasts beautiful luxury vinyl tile flooring throughout, offering both style and durability. Step outside to a lakeside paradise with a composite pier, cozy fire pit area, and a sandy beach perfect for swimming or casting a line. Round Lake is a tranquil 10 MPH lake, ideal for relaxing water activities, and also connects to Little and Big Cedar Lakes—with Big Cedar offering a full 1–4 all-sports experience, including skiing and boating fun. This is the perfect blend of peaceful nature and lakeside recreation—don’t miss your opportunity to own a slice of Indiana lake life!

$485,000 - Columbia City, IN

3255 W Lincolnway Columbia City, IN - Escape to the tranquility of country living with this spacious 4 bedroom, 2.5 bath, two-story home on a full walk-out basement. Nestled on 3.16 picturesque acres, you can enjoy the perfect blend of comfort and adventure with private hiking trails in the woods, a 24’x36 detached garage, and an above ground pool for summer fun. Step inside and discover a warm and inviting layout with spacious kitchen (all kitchen appliances included), breakfast nook, large great room, and an additional space that can be used as a formal dining room or even an office space. Great size main level laundry room with built-in organization cubby. Half bath located between the laundry room and kitchen. Dining area steps out onto the upper level deck that overlooks the pool and picture perfect views. Large primary suite has its own full bath and walk-in closet. 3 additional great size bedrooms can be found on the upper level along with a second full bath with linen closet. The full walk-out basement has multiple rooms that can be set up for a variety of uses. The basement family room steps out onto a spacious patio leading to the pool. Basement also features a 26'x9' mechanical/storage room. The outside is a nature lover's dream with mature trees bordering the property on all sides. A standout feature of this property is its long asphalt driveway, offering smooth access while enhancing privacy and curb appeal. Additionally, there is a 24’x36’ detached garage with electricity and a walk-up staircase leading to an expansive storage area. There is also a 12'x16' shed that will remain with sale. Storage will not be a problem with this property! Whether you're seeking peace, space, or a home ready for entertaining, this property is a must-see.

$424,000 - Columbia City, IN

2605 E Beech Avenue Columbia City, IN - Immediate possession available with this remodeled vinyl sided 4 bedroom 2 bath lake area home with attached 2 car garage and a 32x40 building. Front entry deck leads to the decent sized foyer (with large coat closet) and then flows to the main level featuring: vaulted spacious living room with floor to ceiling gas log stone fireplace, formal dining room with chamfered ceiling, vaulted ceiling center island kitchen (with solid surface counter tops, tile backsplash, appliance package) is open to a vaulted family room with glass slider leading to the 17x27 rear deck overlooking the Thorncreek Township park with pond. The main level also has 3 bedrooms, a full bathroom, front sunroom, and a large laundry/mechanical room (with Whirlpool clothes washer & dryer, new utility sink, new water softener and new water heater). Upper level offers a large landing/home office area (with catwalk overlooking the vaulted main level living room), and a master bedroom suite with walk-in closet and spacious bathroom with vaulted ceiling, skylight, whirlpool tub and separate shower. The attached 23x30 garage is finished and has an electrical sub panel breaker box. Amenities include: fresh interior paint, new floor coverings, new light fixtures/ceiling fans, Anderson windows, high efficiency GFA furnace, central AC, 200 amp breaker box, NIPSCO gas, AEP electric, 4 inch well, regional sewer district. The pole building was constructed by Borkholder Buildings in 1996 and has a 10x10 finished front office area, two overhead doors (front and side), concrete floor with floor drains and a 200 amp breaker box (on a separate electric meter from the house). Ample off-street parking in front of the house and the pole building. Property comes with a pier placed on the north side of Shriner Lake just a few hundred feet from the public access boat ramp. The pier is on DNR state owned land (and not an easement). Shriner Lake is 120 acres and allows skiing from 1 pm to 4 pm. There is also a nearby public access boat ramp on Round Lake which gives water access to Little Cedar Lake and Cedar Lake. A spacious turnkey home in the heart of the popular Tri-Lakes area.

$389,900 - Columbia City, IN

912 E Hawthorn Lane Columbia City, IN - **PRICE REDUCTION & OPEN HOUSE SATURDAY JUNE 7TH FROM 1-3PM** Welcome to this beautifully maintained 3–4 bedroom, 3 full bath ranch-style home, perfectly situated in a convenient Columbia City location. With all major mechanicals updated within the last 6 years, this home offers peace of mind along with style and functionality. Step inside to discover a spacious, open-concept layout featuring a large custom kitchen—complete with ample cabinetry, modern finishes, and plenty of counter space for cooking and entertaining. The cozy living area includes one of two fireplaces, creating a warm, inviting atmosphere throughout. The expansive primary suite boasts a luxurious en suite bath and generous closet space, while additional bedrooms offer flexibility for family, guests, or a home office. The fully finished basement adds significant living space, including the second fireplace, an optional 4th bedroom, full bath, and plenty of room for recreation or relaxation. Enjoy outdoor living in the fully fenced backyard, perfect for pets, kids, and gatherings. Whether you're grilling out or just enjoying the quiet neighborhood, you'll love the space and privacy this yard provides. Located close to schools, shopping, and dining, this move-in-ready home combines comfort, convenience, and value. This type of property does not come along often - schedule your showing today!

$364,846 - Columbia City, IN

1032 S St Rd 205 Columbia City, IN - If you're looking for a spacious family home that combines style, comfort, and functionality, the "Kaden" model by Ideal Builders is a must-see. This exquisite two-story residence boasts 2,480 square feet of thoughtfully designed living space, offering plenty of room for your entire family. From the moment you arrive, you'll be captivated by the home's charm. A three-car garage, partial stone accents, and a welcoming covered front entryway create an inviting first impression. Step inside to a spacious foyer that sets the tone for the rest of the home. Just off the entry, a 16' x 21' flex room provides endless possibilities. Whether you need a home office, formal living area, or playroom. The heart of the home features an open-concept layout, seamlessly connecting the kitchen, dining area, and great room perfect for both everyday living and entertaining. The chef’s kitchen is a true showstopper, featuring an expansive island for extra prep space, custom hickory cabinetry by D & B Cabinet Company with elegant crown molding, premium countertops, and high-end appliances. Upgraded lighting fixtures add a modern touch. A convenient half bath is also located on the main level for guests. Upstairs, you’ll find four spacious bedrooms and a versatile loft, ideal for a cozy relaxation spot. The primary suite is a luxurious retreat, featuring a 14' x 16' bedroom with plenty of natural light, a walk-in closet with a custom Closet Tamers storage system, and an ensuite bath with premium countertops and an upgraded 5' walk-in shower. An additional 3' x 5' linen closet with custom shelving provides extra storage. For ultimate convenience, the second-floor laundry room includes a storage closet and easy attic access. This home is packed with premium upgrades, including a 95% efficient gas furnace, energy-efficient Anderson 100 Series Windows with Low-E Glass help keep utility costs down, while a 50-gallon electric water heater ensures ample hot water. Addt'l features include upgraded locking vinyl plank flooring, rounded drywall corners, 52” ceiling fans, Landmark roof shingles, and a wireless keypad for garage access and a home warranty. To truly appreciate the craftsmanship and attention to detail, schedule your personal tour today. You can also take a virtual walkthrough to explore this beautiful home from the comfort of your own space! *Virtual staging photos added

$354,500 - Columbia City, IN

242 S Cross Creek Way Columbia City, IN - Wonderful 3 bed, 3 bath on a finished, walkout basement. Lovely views from the deck overlooking the wooded back yard. This home is so inviting with cathedral ceilings in living room and a skylight. Quality throughout including solid six panel doors, custom kitchen with granite counters, updated appliances, and walk-in pantry. Step out onto the deck from the dining area to enjoy the peaceful views. The Main floor primary bedroom has an ensuite bath and walk-in closet. Two additional bedrooms and bath plus a laundry room complete the first floor. Lower level has a family room with atrium door to an inviting patio. Large storage room, full bath and a workshop for the hobbyist. Garage has plenty of room and a pull down stair for attic storage. This home has been well cared for and ready for you!

$350,000 - Columbia City, IN

5930 E 500 S Columbia City, IN - 5.51 level acres with mature trees and Massive insulated pole barn with electricity, water, septic, propane, and natural gas on property but not hooked up. The dream was to have a Barndominium and shop all in one. 52 x 48 Structure with 9' ceilings and poured concrete floor currently has kitchen, 1 bed, 1 bath. Living space has wood burning pellet stove for additional heat to the brand new propane furnace. Area also has 3 overhead doors, office and supply room. Additional 24 x 48 Section built in 2017 has 18' ceilings gravel flooring, 2 overhead doors with openers, stairs to loft area with fully insulated ceiling. Remaining R-19 rolls stay with property. Lines for hydro radiant heated flooring in loft is already hung along with pressure tank, tankless water heater, and some mechanicals are partially installed. Septic system and well are presumed to be functioning correctly, but not tested or inspected. Property has frontage on 2 roads, natural gas ability, and electricity already ran. Property is an Estate and is being sold in As-is condition. All inspections are responsibility of buyer. Seller makes no warranties

$349,900 - Columbia City, IN

615 Azuba Court Columbia City, IN - Start Showing Date: 7/16/2025 THE UNICORN YOU'VE BEEN WAITING FOR! This well maintained 3-bed 4 bath home is an entertainer's dream. The huge kitchen features an abundance of cabinets, double oven and an island with overhead hood. The spacious family room is perfect for hosting enormous gatherings. The big primary suite has his and her closets along with its own bathroom. One of the most unique attributes of this home is the 30,000-gal heated pool. The room has its own heat source and comes with its own half bath perfect for year-round enjoyment. Step outside to a fenced backyard that backs up to the serene Holden Lake. A lovely deck provides the ideal space for entertaining or quiet relaxing moments. The fenced in yard ensures safety for the 2- & 4-legged family members. Located on a cul-de-sac this home offers both privacy & peaceful lakeside living. Imagine your holidays watching all the kids enjoy the pool in the middle of the winter. As a BONUS the sellers are leaving the paddleboat & pier. Also, included is a 1-yr home warranty that includes the pool equipment.

$339,500 - Columbia City, IN

3065 E Butler Court Columbia City, IN - Better than new might best describe this immaculate 3 bedroom, 2 bath 1 year old ranch with a spacious 3 car attached garage. Since purchasing new in 2024, seller's have converted the 12' X 10' covered patio into a relaxing 3 seasons room that overlooks the tranquil country setting behind the house. The open concept and split bedroom floor plan provide for a very popular design and the cul de sac street is another bonus providing a low traffic count. Other attractive features includes upgraded maple cabinetry, a large kitchen island with breakfast bar, breakfast room, walk-in pantry and a 5ft walk-in shower in the primary suite. Tax figure does not yet reflect the full assessment.

$335,543 - Columbia City, IN

988 E Hawthorn Lane Columbia City, IN - UNDER CONSTRUCTION: Projected completion is August. 3 Bedroom, 2 Bathroom ranch nestled in Columbia City, near Morches Park, YMCA, Peabody Library & Parkview Whitley Hospital. Spacious owner's suite, A convenient laundry space, kitchen with island. This home offers a 3 car garage.This home offers an extra flex space to use as you wish. Home comes with all kitchen appliances. 5 Star Energy rating and a 10 year structural warranty included.

Columbia City, Indiana listings for sale

End of list

There were no properties mapped for this search