Columbia City Indiana homes for sale starting at Fifty Thousand Dollars

$760,000 - Columbia City, IN

1095 E 600 North Columbia City, IN - Impressive 6,500+ square foot home perched on a hill overlooking 3.5 acres. With 5 large size bedrooms, 5.5 bathrooms, and a full basement equipped for a mother-in-law suite, this home is perfect for multigenerational living, hosting guests, or everyday living, all while experiencing country living. From the moment you walk in you’re greeted with a 2 story foyer, decorative archways, wood beams, double staircase, and massive landing space above the entrance. The main floor boasts a spacious living area with two story high cathedral ceilings & remote controlled gas fireplace. You'll love the open-concept gourmet kitchen with marble floors, custom granite countertops, two walk-in pantries, coffee bar, and ample tall cabinet space. The main level also offers a formal dining room, second living room, mudroom off the garage, and a spacious sunroom that walks out to the back deck. There are primary en-suites located on both the main level and upstairs as well. The primary suite on the second floor is truly impressive in size and features cathedral ceilings, a sitting area with 2 way gas fireplace, spacious walk-in closet, and en-suite bathroom with double sink vanity, jetted tub, large dual shower heads, linen closet, and heated floors. The second floor also has 3 more bedrooms, a huge bonus room over the garage, laundry hook up, and large hallway overlooking the front foyer and living room. Lastly, the full finished basement can be accessed from both inside the house and also a separate entrance from the garage. The basement offers a huge entertaining space, kitchenette, the 5th full bathroom, and 3 additional rooms for workout space, theatre room, family room etc. Additional features of the home to highlight include: remote control shades, washer and dryer hookup on each floor, 9 ft ceilings, dual furnaces, new concrete walkway/front porch, and 35' x20' 3 car garage with 11" ceiling and service door. This home has so much to offer in a fantastic country setting. Be sure to check out the video and schedule your in person tour!

$699,900 - Columbia City, IN

5595 N State Road 109 Columbia City, IN - Welcome to this quality-built Cape Cod-style home offering over 3,600 sq ft of finished living space and an additional 2,500+ sq ft of unfinished basement—ready for your vision. Nestled far off the road for privacy and peace, this 5-bedroom, 4-bathroom home is surrounded by a beautiful partially wooded setting with a 1-acre stocked pond, perfect for outdoor enjoyment and sunset views. Inside, you'll love the sprawling kitchen with abundant cabinetry, countertop space, and all appliances included. The main level features 3 bedrooms, including a spacious master suite with his-and-her walk-in closets, dual vanity, jetted tub, and walk-in shower. A formal dining room adds elegance just off the entryway. Upstairs, a massive family room separates two additional bedrooms—ideal for guests or a home office setup. This home includes geothermal heating and cooling, a cozy propane fireplace in the living room, and an oversized 22x30 two-car garage. Built in 2001 and located less than half a mile from Northern Heights Elementary, this is the perfect blend of convenience, space, and tranquility. Don't miss this one-of-a-kind opportunity in a prime location!

$699,000 - Columbia City, IN

804 Wexford Court Columbia City, IN - Beautiful stucco home with circle drive on 3 acres with a shared pond. The custom home has 4 bedrooms and 4 baths. The office comes with a built-in desk and bookshelf. Custom kitchen with quartz countertops. Large 3 season room and a pergola with hanging lights above the large deck. The yard has a full irrigation system. The finished basement is very open with a wet bar. The large storage area in the garage has an overhead door. The pool table and the treadmill stay with the house as well.

$650,000 - Columbia City, IN

2624 E Stalf Road Columbia City, IN - Open House This Sunday 6/29 from 1-3 PM !! Where every single day feels like a vacation - without ever leaving home. Welcome to this beautiful lakefront oasis on the shores of Little Cedar lake with your very own sandy bottom beach! Enjoy the quiet tranquility of no wake waters right outside your door while still having all of the perks of the nearby action. Just a quick ride under the bridge gives you full access to Big Cedar Lake, ideal for boating, swimming, water sports (with fast time from 1-4), and any and all summertime fun. Immediately upon entry, you'll be captivated by the expansive floor to ceiling windows, flooding the space with natural light and showcasing the stunning, uninterrupted views of the sparkling blue waters. An airy, open concept living space features dramatic vaulted ceilings, built in shelving, elevated bamboo flooring, and a fireplace for some added warmth and character. The updated kitchen is equally impressive, offering quartz countertops, updated finishes, and panoramic views of the lake. An adjacent dining area lets you soak up the beauty of the water with every meal. Upstairs, the primary suite is sure to please featuring tray ceilings with ambient lighting, sliding glass doors to your private balcony overlooking the water, and a recently updated en suite bathroom complete with granite countertops, tiled shower, and upscale light fixtures. Guests will appreciate their own touch of luxury with a beautifully updated bathroom conveniently located adjacent to the guest bedroom, alongside an additional versatile room ideal for an office or extra bedroom. On the third level, a spacious loft offers flexibility for a fourth bedroom, office, or recreational space kept cool in the summer and cozy in the winter with a dedicated mini split system. Step outside to discover an impeccably landscaped, courtyard style setting featuring a composite deck and spacious patio - perfectly designed for a hot tub, grilling, entertaining guests, or simply unwinding and taking in the lakefront views. A fenced, grassy area offers the ideal space for pets to roam, while a nearby shed provides convenient storage for kayaks, lake gear, and lawn equipment. Enjoy 40 feet of lake frontage complete with a private pier and sandy bottom shoreline beach, creating your own slice of summer paradise. Live where every day feels like a vacation. Schedule your private showing today.

$634,900 - Columbia City, IN

2161 E Crampton Road Columbia City, IN - Seller offering up to $10,000 in closing costs/rate buy down or boat will remain with the property! Experience the pinnacle of lakeside luxury in this exquisitely remodeled 4-level home on the highly coveted Big Cedar Lake, part of the popular Tri-Lakes area where you can indulge in waterskiing daily from 1-4 p.m. Offering breathtaking panoramic views and meticulous attention to detail in every corner, this residence is the embodiment of elegance and comfort. As you step inside, you're immediately welcomed by a cheery living room bathed in natural light from expansive windows, creating an airy and inviting ambiance. The open concept design effortlessly flows into the gourmet kitchen and dining area, a true chef's haven. Here, quartz countertops glisten under the soft lighting, complementing the top-of-the-line stainless steel appliances. The rich hickory cabinetry provides ample storage, while a spacious pantry offers added convenience. The dining room is anchored by a striking gas fireplace with a shiplap mantel and elegant brick accents, enhancing the room's sophisticated charm. Descending to the lower level, you’ll find the lavish primary suite, a sanctuary of tranquility. French doors open to a covered patio that invites you to unwind while gazing over the serene lake. The suite features expansive walk-in closets and an ensuite designed for ultimate relaxation. Indulge in the double vanity, luxuriate in the glass and herringbone-tiled shower with multiple shower heads, or soak away the day in the deep, freestanding tub. The home includes three additional beautifully appointed bedrooms, one of which is situated on the main level and could easily serve as a second primary suite. This room is complemented by a generous closet and an elegant full bath with a tiled shower/tub combination. The fourth level offers a unique and playful space with a cozy "cubby" as well as a built-in lofted "room", evoking the whimsical feel of a treehouse. Outside, the property continues to impress with a deck and a covered patio, both designed for effortless entertaining or peaceful relaxation. The property’s newer dock, which remains with the home, is ideal for mooring your pontoon or other watercraft. Directly across from the main residence, a separate lot features a 35X27 4-car garage, offering ample space for vehicles, lake toys, and guest parking.This lakeside haven is not just a home it’s a refined retreat where luxury meets nature!

$585,900 - Columbia City, IN

5155 E 200 N Columbia City, IN - Still Accepting Offers! *Open Houses - Thursday (5/15) from 5 to 7, and Sunday (5/18) from 1 to 3* Welcome to this stunning 19.3-acre homestead, situated between Columbia City and Churubusco—just 15 minutes from Fort Wayne. This charming 3-bedroom, 2-bath ranch offers 1,559 finished sq ft of living space with an additional 780 sq ft open basement. Recent upgrades include new vinyl siding, Universal windows, and Universal/Andersen sliding patio doors (2024). A durable metal roof and new well pump were added in 2017, along with a highly efficient Water Furnace 5 Series geothermal heat pump system (2013). Appliances, including a washer and dryer, are included. Interior enhancements from 2017 include new carpet in the living and dining rooms, recessed lighting, re-insulated ceilings finished with Spanish Lace texture, fresh paint in the main living area, and solid Texas Cedar mission-style interior doors. Enjoy panoramic views from the covered front porch or relax under the pergola on the spacious rear deck. Zoned agricultural, this property has it all: manicured lawn, tillable fields, and fenced pastures for livestock. The 36x48 outbuilding features a loft with capacity for 1,000 hay bales—ideal for horse owners or hobby farmers. Currently, the fields are leased to a neighbor, offering potential for annual crop income. The land also provides an abundance of flowering perennials and homegrown produce such as strawberries, concord grapes, and mulberries. If you’re searching for a peaceful country lifestyle with low taxes and minimal utility costs (electric is the only utility), look no further. This semi self-sustaining homestead is a rare find.

$579,900 - Columbia City, IN

275 E Morsches Road Columbia City, IN - Accepted Contingent Offer Accepting Backup Offers. Waterfront living at its best! Immaculate 2x6 construction with 4 bedrooms, 3 full baths (2 baths have heated floors), large great room with 9 ft ceilings, custom cabinets, quartz countertops, breakfast bar, R/O drinking H2O in kitchen and instant hot H2O in kitchen. The first floor is handicap accessible, screened-in porch to enjoy spectacular views, oversized attached garage with workshop, approximately 81 ft of lakefront. All appliances & pier remain. Crooked Lake is one of the deepest cleanest lakes in Northern Indiana, a beautiful recreational lake.

$564,900 - Columbia City, IN

3219 E Colony Avenue Columbia City, IN - First Right offer accepted. Tri-Lakes gem that provides beautiful unobstructed views all year long. Known for its spring fed water and sandy bottom makes Round Lake a very desirable location. As part of the Tri-Lakes chain you have access to both Little Cedar and all sports Big Cedar Lake You will love having 100 ft of lake frontage plus an extra 100 ft frontage on the additional channel lot across the road. Inside this completely remodeled home you'll be greeted with all new modern touches and an open concept floor plan. Both the living room and kitchen has plenty of natural lighting and a clear unobstructed view of the lake. A large deck for outdoor entertaining or quietly enjoying the lake is assessable from both the living room and primary bedroom. The primary bedroom en suite also includes a fireplace surrounded by the built-in shelves and storage, The main floor includes two more bedrooms, a full bathroom and a laundry room with space for a full-size washer and dryer. The downstairs has a family room with a fireplace and a separate office. Rarely do you find a lake home with plenty of parking for all your visitors. The detached 2-car garage and large shed provide plenty of storage for all your lake toys. This home is on the end of a dead-end street. Newer roof, new siding, windows and HVAC. New interior and exterior doors plus new garage doors. New driveway, walkways and landscaping. This is a perfect place on the water and with its close proximity to both Fort Wayne and Warsaw could have you staying all summer or moving to the lake permanently!

$544,900 - Columbia City, IN

3598 W Huntington Ave 57 Avenue Columbia City, IN - Come check out this completely renovated 4 bedroom 3 bathroom property at Big Lake! This open floor plan house has been entirely renovated including furnace, central air, plumbing, electrical, kitchen, floors, baths, and more. This home has laced walls and ceilings throughout. The kitchen has been complete with quartz counter tops and cabinets with soft close doors and drawers. Enjoy time out on the spacious deck or take a short walk down to the lake. Come take a look at this beautiful home!

$524,900 - Columbia City, IN

3775 W Columbia Street Columbia City, IN - Wake up every day to breathtaking, unobstructed views of Big Lake from this spacious 6-bedroom, nearly 3,000 sq. ft. home. Thoughtfully designed with 2x6 construction and bathed in natural light, the home showcases spectacular sunsets from its westerly-facing windows and expansive composite wrap-around deck with low-maintenance vinyl railings. The kitchen features an eat-up bar—perfect for entertaining—while the primary suite offers a private retreat with an en suite bath. A massive garage with high ceilings includes a walk-up stairway to a generous storage area accessible from both the garage and the upper level of the home. Another great feature is the tall crawl space with lighting, concrete walls and flooring. Located on all-sports Big Lake, enjoy unlimited speed from 1–4 p.m., perfect for boating, jet skiing, and lakeside fun. This is your chance to own a great home in a truly unbeatable setting!

Columbia City, Indiana listings for sale

End of list

There were no properties mapped for this search